Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeanceTreston, Hubert Joseph
History
Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeance
Treston, Hubert Joseph
Criminal law (Greek law); Greece -- Civilization; Greek drama (Tragedy) -- History and criticism; Homicide (Greek law); Vendetta
The first passage is from the _Odyssey_[149] and is concerned with
King Oedipus the parricide and with his punishment. Odysseus narrates
how, in Hades, he saw Epicaste, and how ‘he that had slain his father
wedded her and straightway the gods made known these things to men. Yet
he abode in pain in pleasant Thebes, ruling the Cadmeans, by reason of
the baneful devices of the gods. She indeed went down to Hades ... but
for him she left behind many a woe, such as the Erinnyes of a mother
bring to pass.’ Of all forms of homicide, that by which a son deprived
a parent of life was regarded as the most horrible. Probably even the
Achaeans, as we shall see presently, felt a certain horror at the thought
of parricide. Homer, then, cannot understand why the gods, who had taken
the trouble of revealing the crimes of Oedipus, nevertheless permitted,
if they did not encourage, his continued rule over the Cadmeans. All
other parricides of whom Homer had ever heard had taken to flight! And
what was the pain which Oedipus endured? Was it remorse of conscience?
Or was it his self-inflicted blindness? Euripides[150] tells how the
sons of Oedipus confined their father under bolts and hid him away that
his sad fate might be forgotten. We shall see, later, when we analyse
the Oedipodean legends as given by the Attic dramatists, how Oedipus is
filled with natural grief, but is free from that sense of moral guilt
which we should expect him to have felt. He constantly pleads that he
did not know that the man whom he slew was Laius, his father. Was this
plea invented in later years, or was it part of the original legend?
Seebohm[151] has told us that in primitive clan societies ‘accidental
homicide within the kindred does not seem to be followed even by exile.’
Was it, then, because of ‘accidental’ or involuntary[152] parricide that
Oedipus continued to rule over the Cadmeans? Oedipus was not an Achaean.
Minoan or Cadmean, which was he? It does not matter, for our purpose, if
he obeyed the ‘dooms’ of private vengeance in tribal society. Homer is
equally vague about the working of the mother’s curse. Why did Epicaste
curse Oedipus? The Attic dramatists do not mention this. Oedipus is
cursed in Homer for one reason, and, as we think, for one reason only.
It is because other slayers of kinsmen who did not suffer punishment
were usually cursed. Thus Meleager, who in a quarrel slew his uncle,
was cursed by his mother Althaea.[153] It is an Homeric maxim that the
Erinnyes command men to honour their parents.[154]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account