Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeanceTreston, Hubert Joseph
History
Poine: a study in ancient Greek blood-vengeance
Treston, Hubert Joseph
Criminal law (Greek law); Greece -- Civilization; Greek drama (Tragedy) -- History and criticism; Homicide (Greek law); Vendetta
Our next quotation has reference to Tydeus, the brother of Meleager.
Homer[47] tells us that Tydeus left his native Calydon, and ‘roaming
thence settled at Argos, (for thus did Zeus and other gods decree,)
and married there a daughter of Adrastus.’ In this connexion Leaf[48]
points out that ‘Homer does not tell of any actual homicide, yet the
picture he gives of the family feuds in Tydeus’ time is such as to make
family bloodshed far from improbable.’ From later legends[49] we learn
what Homer has not mentioned, namely, that Tydeus was a kin-slayer. We
know that Tydeus was an Achaean, and his action in fleeing from Calydon
and settling at Argos was a typical Achaean procedure. His ‘exile’ was
really a flight from death, and such a flight suggests that even in the
case of kin-slaying the Achaeans, unlike the Pelasgians, did not accept
‘exile’ as a penalty for bloodshed. This has already been demonstrated in
connexion with the flight of Theoclymenus.[50] The alliance of Tydeus,
by marriage, with Adrastus, King of Argos, helped to preclude the
possibility of blood-vengeance at the hands of Calydonian avengers.
A clear and cogent illustration of the Achaean system of avenging
bloodshed is to be found in the punishment inflicted by Orestes on
his mother and her paramour in revenge for the slaying of Agamemnon.
It is not of course a matter of absolute certainty that Orestes slew
his mother or that she slew her husband, in the Homeric story, but
it can, we think, be inferred with the greatest probability. Homer
says[51] that, after the Trojan war, Menelaus wandered about with his
ships ‘amongst men of strange speech’ for seven years: that meanwhile
‘Aegisthus planned baneful deeds at home: and for seven years ruled
over rich Mycenae, having wrought the death of the son of Atreus, and
subdued unto himself the people: but in the eighth year goodly Orestes
came back from Athens as a retribution and slew the man guilty of his
father’s blood (πατροφονῆα), Aegisthus of crafty counsel, who had wrought
his father’s death. Now when he had slain him, he held a funeral feast
with the Argives for his hateful mother and for Aegisthus powerless in
defence (ἀνάλκιδος).’ In this rendering of the text, we have deliberately
avoided translating κτείνειν as ‘to slay,’ since it can also mean ‘to
seek to slay’[52] or, which is almost equivalent, ‘to plot the death
of.’ From the point of view of homicide-guilt and retribution, the
plotter and the perpetrator were probably equally culpable whether in
the Homeric epoch or in historical times.[53] Hence it is that in other
passages Homer presents Clytaemnestra as the plotter and Aegisthus
as the executor. In both cases, of course, the guilt of bloodshed is
aggravated by the additional stigma of adultery. In the _Odyssey_[54]
Zeus tells how he warned Aegisthus not to kill Agamemnon or to woo his
wife, for Agamemnon would be avenged by Orestes. Again,[55] we are told
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account