Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the authorHelmholtz, Hermann von
Science
Popular lectures on scientific subjects : $b Second series, with an autobiography of the author
Helmholtz, Hermann von
Science; Universities and colleges -- Germany
It is, in fact, no easy problem to ascertain completely the origins of
our knowledge. An enormous amount is transmitted by speech and writing.
This power which man possesses of gathering together the stores of
knowledge of generations, is the chief reason of his superiority over
the animal, who is restricted to an inherited blind instinct and to
its individual experience. But all transmitted knowledge is handed
on already formed; whence the reporter has derived it, or how much
criticism he has bestowed upon it, can seldom be made out, especially
if the tradition has been handed down through several generations. We
must admit it all upon good faith; we cannot arrive at the source; and
when many generations have contented themselves with such knowledge,
have brought no criticism to bear upon it; have, indeed, gradually
added all kinds of small alterations, which ultimately grew up to large
ones--after all this, strange things are often reported and believed
under the authority of primeval wisdom. A curious case of this kind is
the history of the circulation of the blood, of which we shall still
have to speak.
But another kind of tradition by speech, which long remained
undetected, is even still more confusing for one who reflects upon
the origin of knowledge. Speech cannot readily develop names for
classes of objects or for classes of processes, if we have not
been accustomed very often to mention together the corresponding
individuals, things, and separate cases, and to assert what there is
in common about them. They must, therefore, possess many points in
common. Or if we, reflecting scientifically upon this, select some
of these characteristics, and collate them to form a definition, the
common possession of these selected characteristics must necessitate
that in the given cases a great number of other characteristics are
to be regularly met with; there must be a natural connection between
the first and the last named characteristics. If, for instance, we
assign the name of mammals to those animals which, when young, are
suckled by their mothers, we can assert further, in reference to
them, that they are all warm-blooded animals, born alive, that they
have a spinal column but no quadrate bone, breathe through lungs,
have separate divisions of the heart, &c. Hence the fact, that in the
speech of an intelligent observing people a certain class of things are
included in one name, indicates that these things or cases fall under
a common natural relationship; by this alone a host of experiences are
transmitted from preceding generations without this appearing to be the
case.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account