Popular misgovernment in the United StatesCruikshank, Alfred Byron
History
Popular misgovernment in the United States
Cruikshank, Alfred Byron
Suffrage -- United States; United States -- Politics and government
“The rôle of the French Deputy is today largely that of a sort of
_chargé d’affaires_ sent to Paris to see that its constituency
obtains its share of the favors which the government has for
distribution. Instead, therefore, of occupying himself with
questions of legislation of interest to the country as a whole, he
is engaged in playing the rôle of a mendicant for his petty
district. He spends his time in the ante-rooms of the ministers
soliciting favors for his political supporters and grants for his
arrondissement.”
Sometimes the constituents ask the deputy to procure nurses for their
families, or to do shopping. Some want appointments as vendors of
tobacco; the ministers, to purchase their support, agree to appoint
their friends to office, give them decorations and advance them
politically. The deputy must look for appropriations for local
railroads, repairs for churches, pictures for the exhibition, public
fountains, monuments. All the school teachers, tobacconists, road
overseers and letter carriers are expected to work for him. (_American
Political Science Review_, Vol. 7, p. 617.) An interesting book has
recently been published by a member of the French Academy, in which he
accuses democracy of having an inevitable tendency to produce
inefficiency in government. He testifies that such has been the
experience in France. It is in the very spirit of democracy, he says, to
favor incompetence in all public officials. (_Cult of Incompetence_,
Faguet.)
This lowering of the official standards has been observed elsewhere,
wherever manhood suffrage obtains. Mr. E. L. Godkin, a distinguished New
York publicist, writing some years ago said:
“There is not a country in the world living under parliamentary
government which has not begun to complain of the quality of its
legislators. More and more it is said the work of government is
falling into the hands of men to whom even small pay is important
and who are suspected of adding to their income by corruption.”
(_Unforeseen Tendencies of Democracy_, p. 117.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account