[Footnote 119: In emphasising here the weak sides of the writings of
Plato and Aristotle, forced on my attention while reading them in
German translations, I, of course, have no intention of underrating
the great merits and the high historical importance of these two
men. Their importance must not be measured by the fact that our
speculative philosophy still moves to a great extent in their paths
of thought. The more probable conclusion is that this branch has
made very little progress in the last two thousand years. Natural
science also was implicated for centuries in the meshes of the
Aristotelian thought, and owes its rise mainly to having thrown off
those fetters.]
[Footnote 120: I would not for a moment contend that we derive
exactly the same profit from reading a Greek author in a translation
as from reading him in the original; but the difference, the excess
of gain in the second case, appears to me, and probably will to most
men who are not professional philologists, to be too dearly bought
with the expenditure of eight years of valuable time.]
[Footnote 121: "The temptation," Judge Hartwich writes, "to regard
the 'taste' of the ancients as so lofty and unsurpassable appears to
me to have its chief origin in the fact that the ancients were
unexcelled in the representation of the nude. First, by their
unremitting care of the human body they produced splendid models;
and secondly, in their gymnasiums and in their athletic games they
had these models constantly before their eyes. No wonder, then, that
their statues still excite our admiration! For the form, the ideal
of the human body has not changed in the course of the centuries.
But with intellectual matters it is totally different; they change
from century to century, nay, from decennium to decennium. It is
very natural now, that people should unconsciously apply what is
thus so easily seen, namely, the works of sculpture, as a universal
criterion of the highly developed taste of the ancients--a fallacy
against which people cannot, in my judgment, be too strongly
warned."]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account