Portuguese literatureBell, Aubrey F. G. (Aubrey Fitz Gerald)
History
Portuguese literature
Bell, Aubrey F. G. (Aubrey Fitz Gerald)
Portuguese literature -- History and criticism
common use, although some severe critics have censured him for this,
considering the use of latinized forms a defect in his poem’.[427]
An inch farther than he went in this direction, or in that of _furia
grande e sonorosa_, and _estilo grandiloquo_, would have been an inch
too far, and subsequent writers did not always observe his restraint,
the sobriety due to his classical education. But his poem certainly
helped to fix the language, and he cannot be blamed for the excesses of
his followers, or for a change which had begun before his time.[428]
Couto records the theft of the _Parnaso_ in which Camões was collecting
his lyrics with a view to publishing them. He must have written many
more lyrics than we possess, but even so the number existing is not
small. Successive editors have added to them from time to time, and
often clumsily. Faria e Sousa, a century after Camões’ death, declared
that he had added 200, and, while upbraiding Diogo Bernardez for
his _robos_, was himself the thief. Camões might have been somewhat
surprised to find in the first edition of his lyrics (1595) two poems
which had been in print in the _Cancioneiro de Resende_ eight years
before he was born. This 1595 edition contained but 65 sonnets, but
their number grew to 108 (1598), 140 (1616), 229 (1668), 296 (1685),
352 (1860), 354 (1873). D. Carolina Michaëlis de Vasconcellos has
already contributed much towards a critical edition, and it is to
be hoped that before long it may be possible to read the genuine
lyrics of Camões in a complete edition by themselves.[429] That would
certainly cause him to be more widely read abroad. It is perhaps
inevitable that a comparison should arise between Camões and Petrarca
(although it must be remembered that they are separated by two
centuries), yet he would be an extremely bold or extremely ignorant
critic who should place the one of them above the other. In genius
they were equal, but a different atmosphere acted on their genius, the
artistic atmosphere of Italy and the natural atmosphere of Portugal.
Petrarca was the more scholarly writer, so that if he perhaps never
attains to the rapturous heights occasionally reached by Camões, he
also keeps himself from the blemishes which sometimes disfigure Camões’
work. Camões’ life was far more varied, many-coloured as an Alentejan
_manta_,[430] and this is reflected in his poems. Intensely human, he
is swayed by many moods, while Petrarca is merged in the narrower flame
of his love. Petrarca excels him in the sonnet, for although many of
those by Camões are beautiful, and nearly all contain some beautiful
passage, he was not really at his ease in this scanty plot of ground.
His genius required a larger canvas for its expression. The following
lines from his long and magnificent _canção Vinde cá_ are worth quoting
because they triumphantly display many of the noblest characteristics
of his poetry:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account