Practicable Socialism, New SeriesBarnett, S. A. (Samuel Augustus)
Religion
Practicable Socialism, New Series
Barnett, S. A. (Samuel Augustus)
Great Britain -- Social conditions -- 19th century; Social problems; Working class
The revelation of the abuse is itself a valuable contribution to the
needs of the time. The public, unless they know the extent of the
mischief, will never be moved to the necessary effort of reform; and
teachers of the public, through the Pulpit and the Press, could hardly
do better than publish extracts from the Report showing the waste of
money, the demoralization, the ill-will, which gathers round workhouses,
casual wards and out relief.
The ordinary reader of this evidence might naturally inquire, “What has
the Local Government Board been doing to prevent the abuses which it
must have known? Why, if conviction was not possible, was not Parliament
asked for further powers or for some reform? What is the use of
inspectors? Why should a controlling department exist if the nation is
to stand convicted of such neglect, and to be brought into such danger?”
The Report implies, indeed, some slight blame to the Local Government
Board, because it did not at all times afford sufficient direction; and
the Minority Report, in its more trenchant way, sometimes emphasizes the
confusion it has caused by its varying decisions; but the thought
naturally occurs that if the Board had not been so strongly represented
on the Commission, or if a body representative of the best guardians
were called on to render a report, the supreme authority which has so
long known the evil and done so little for its reform would have been
roundly condemned.
The Commissioners, however, pass their judgment on the system, and
proceed to make their recommendations. There are two sets, those of the
Majority and those of the Minority. They extend over 1238 large pages,
and deal with thousands of details. A close examination is therefore
impossible in a short article, but there are certain tests by which the
principal recommendations may be tried. I would try just two such tests:
(1) Do they make it possible to relieve needs without demoralizing
character? (2) Do they stimulate energy without raising the devil in
human nature?
The people who need relief are roughly divided into two great classes,
“the unable” and “the able”. The recommendations of the Report--Majority
and Minority--as they affect these two classes may be tried by the
suggested test.
THE UNABLE.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account