English poetry -- 19th century -- History and criticism; Pre-Raphaelitism in literature
First, as to the man himself. We must not suppose that a person is
necessarily immoral in his life because he happens to write something
which is immoral, any more than we should suppose a person whose
writings are extremely moral to be incapable of doing anything of
a vicious or foolish kind. Shelley, for example, is a very chaste
poet--there is not one improper line in the whole of his poetry; but
his life was decidedly unfortunate. Exactly the reverse happens in
the case of Swinburne, who has written thousands of immoral lines.
The fact is that many persons are apt to mistake artistic feeling
for vicious feeling, and a spirit of revolt against conventions for a
general hatred of moral law. I must ask you to try to put yourselves
for a moment in the place of a young student, such as Swinburne was
at the time of these writings, and try to imagine how he felt about
things. In every Western boy--indeed, I may say in every civilised
boy--there are several distinct periods, corresponding to the various
periods in the history of human progress. Both psychologically and
physiologically the history of the race is repeated in the history
of the individual. The child is a savage, without religion, without
tenderness, with a good deal of cruelty and cunning in his little soul.
He is this because the first faculties that are developed within him
are the faculties for self-preservation, the faculties of primitive
man. Then ideas of right and wrong and religious feelings are quickened
within him by home-training, and he becomes somewhat like the man
of the Middle Ages--he enters into his mediæval period. Then in the
course of his college studies he is gradually introduced to a knowledge
of the wonderful old Greek civilisation, civilisation socially and,
in some respects, even morally superior to anything in the existing
world; and he enters into the period of his Renaissance. If he be very
sensitive to beauty, if he have the æsthetic faculty largely developed,
there will almost certainly come upon him an enthusiastic love and
reverence for the old paganism, and a corresponding dislike of his
modern surroundings. This feeling may last only for a short time, or
it may change his whole life. One fact to observe is this, that it is
just about the time when a young man's passions are strongest that the
story of Greek life is suddenly expounded to him in the course of his
studies; and you must remember that the æsthetic faculty is primarily
based upon the sensuous life. Now in Swinburne's case we have an
abnormal æsthetic and scholarly faculty brought into contact with these
influences at a very early age; and the result must have been to that
young mind like the shock of an earth-quake. We must also imagine the
natural consequence of this enthusiasm in a violent reaction against
all literary, religious, or social conventions that endeavour to keep
the spirit of the old paganism hidden and suppressed within narrow
limits, as a dangerous thing.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account