Prejudices, fifth seriesMencken, H. L. (Henry Louis)
History
Prejudices, fifth series
Mencken, H. L. (Henry Louis)
American essays -- 20th century; American literature -- History and criticism; Literature -- History and criticism
The extent to which Protestantism, in its upper reaches, has succumbed
to the harlotries of Rome seems to be but little apprehended by the
majority of connoisseurs. I was myself unaware of the whole truth until
last Christmas, when, in the pursuit of a quite unrelated inquiry,
I employed agents to attend all the services held in the principal
Protestant basilicas of an eminent American city, and to bring in the
best reports they could formulate upon what went on in the lesser
churches. The substance of these reports, in so far as they related
to churches patronized by the well-to-do, was simple: they revealed a
headlong movement to the right, an almost precipitate flight over the
mountain. Six so-called Episcopal churches held midnight services on
Christmas Eve in obvious imitation of Catholic midnight masses, and one
of them actually called its service a solemn high mass. Two invited the
nobility and gentry to processions, and a third concealed a procession
under the name of a pageant. One offered Gounod’s St. Cecilia mass
on Christmas morning, and another the Messe Solennelle by the same
composer; three others, somewhat more timorous, contented themselves
with parts of masses. One, throwing off all pretense and euphemism,
summoned the faithful to no less than three Christmas masses, naming
them by name--two low and one high. All six churches were aglow with
candles, and two employed incense.
But that was not the worst. Two Presbyterian churches and one Baptist
church, not to mention five Lutheran churches of different synods, had
choral services in the dawn of Christmas morning, and the one attended
by the only one of my agents who got up early enough--it was in a
Presbyterian church--was made gay with candles, and had a palpably
Roman smack. Yet worse: a rich and conspicuous Methodist church,
patronized by the leading Wesleyan wholesalers and money-lenders of the
town, boldly offered a mediæval carol service. Mediæval? What did that
mean? The Middle Ages ended on July 16, 1453, at 12 o’clock meridian,
and the Reformation was not launched by Luther until October 31, 1517,
at 10.15 A. M. If mediæval, in the sense in which it was here used,
does not mean Roman Catholic, then I surely went to school in vain.
My agent, born a Methodist, reported that the whole ceremony shocked
him excessively. It began with trumpet blasts from the church spire
and it concluded with an Ave Maria by a vested choir! Candles rose
up in glittering ranks behind the chancel rail, and above them glowed
a shining electric star. God help us all, indeed! What next? Will the
rev. pastor, on some near to-morrow, defy the lightnings of Jahveh by
appearing in alb and dalmatic? Will he turn his back upon the faithful?
Will he put in a telephone-booth for auricular confession? I shudder to
think of what old John Wesley would have said about that vested choir
and that shining star. Or Bishop Francis Asbury. Or the Rev. Jabez
Bunting. Or Robert Strawbridge, that consecrated man.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account