Premature Burial and How It May Be PreventedTebb, William
Science
Premature Burial and How It May Be Prevented
Tebb, William
Burial, Premature
One of the most distinguished physicians in London informed the author
that, being called in to decide a case of apparent or real death, he
had applied the stethoscope and failed to detect the faintest pulsation
in the heart, and yet the woman recovered. The danger of premature
burial he believed to be very real and by no means an imaginary one,
and his opinions were well known in the profession.
THE RESPIRATORY TEST.
Sir Benjamin Ward Richardson, in his paper on “The Absolute Signs and
Proofs of Death,” in the _Asclepiad_, No. 21 (1889), vol. vi., p. 6,
says:--
“About the existence of respiratory movements there is always some
cause for doubt, even amongst skilled observers; for so slight a
movement of respiration is sufficient to carry on life, at what I have
in another paper designated ‘life at low tension,’ the most practised
eye is apt to be deceived.”
“The cessation of the indications of respiratory function, although
useful in a general sense, is not by any means reliable. It is quite
certain that in poisoning by chloral, and in catalepsy, there may be
life when no external movement of the chest is appreciable.”--_Ibidem,
pp. 13, 14._
CARDIAC AND ARTERIAL FAILURE TEST.
“Equal doubt attends the absence of the arterial pulsations and heart
sounds. It is quite certain that the pulses of the body, as well as the
movements and sounds of the heart, may be undetectable at a time when
the body is not only not dead but actually recoverable.”--_Ibidem, p.
14._
In a review of several works on the “Signs of Death” in _The British
and Foreign Medical and Chirurgical Review_, vol. XV. [1855], p. 74,
W. B. Kesteven writes that Bouchut’s test of the cessation of the
action of the heart for one or two minutes is not to be relied upon
as a certain sign of death. “M. Josat has recorded several instances
wherein newly-born children have been most carefully examined during
several minutes without the detection of the slightest cardial sound or
movement, and yet these have rallied and lived. M. Depaul has collected
ten similar instances. M. Brachet has recorded[14] an instance of a
man in whom neither sound nor movement of the heart could be heard for
eight minutes, and who, nevertheless, survived. Another adult case
is mentioned by Dr. Josat as having been witnessed by M. Girbal, of
Montpellier.... Sir B. Brodie and others have described children born
without hearts. The circulation is maintained at one period of human
life without the aid of the heart. It is, besides, quite consistent
with the facts observed in hysterical and other conditions of the
nervous system, that the action of the heart, like that of other
muscles, should be so extremely feeble as not to be cognisable by any
sound or impulse, and yet it may have sufficient movement slowly to
move the blood through the system, whose every function and endowment
is suspended and all but annihilated. In cases of catalepsy, and of
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account