Ireland -- Politics and government -- 1901-1910; Land tenure -- Ireland
The most remarkable and the worst effect--with a revolutionary tendency in
no doubtful sense--of this mischievous system has, however, to be still
noticed. About one out of ten of the agricultural tenants of Ireland have
'purchased' their farms in the way described; the fund available for 'land
purchase' cannot include more than one in five; and the process is and
must be slow, owing to the law's delay. Legislation, therefore, with a
singular want of insight, has drawn, and is drawing, an unjust distinction
between 'purchasing' and rent-paying tenants; it is dividing them into a
small favoured class, and a multitude harshly left out in the cold--fat
sheep in one fold, lean goats in another; as the inevitable result, the
rent-paying tenant resents the benefits obtained by 'the purchaser;' and
the immense majority of the farmers of Ireland are made discontented with
their lot, from their point of view not without reason. It is idle to say
to this great body of men that they have already gained advantages from
the State, on which they never reckoned thirty years ago, and that they
have the 'Three F's,' and all that the phrase implies; those who have
secured much are eager to secure more; the unfair distinction arbitrarily
made against them is unintelligible and exasperating, man being what he
is. The policy of 'voluntary purchase,' as it is called, has, accordingly,
from the very nature of the case, provoked and called into being the cry
for the 'compulsory purchase' of the Irish land, now being heard far and
wide in Ireland--that is, for the forcible expropriation of all Irish
landlords, and for placing all their tenants, in their stead, as owners of
their estates. This demand has as yet been rejected by statesmen, and is,
I believe, both hopeless and shameful; but it has, nevertheless, some
logic on its side; it is a corollary from legislation essentially bad;
and, backed as it is by a large force of Irish opinion, it cannot be
ignored or treated with contempt. It is simply extraordinary that many
Irish landlords have been encouraging, and still encourage, 'voluntary
purchase,' on its existing lines, and will not perceive that it leads to
'compulsory purchase;' either from a desire to dispose of parts of their
estates, or from motives not easy to understand, they are promoting a
revolution, which, if accomplished, would assure their ruin, as I shall
conclusively prove afterwards. But the well-informed and most thoughtful
members of their class are not flies lured into a bottle by a bit of
sugar; they are alive to all that is involved in what is called 'land
purchase.' Many years ago, when Parliament was voting funds for 'voluntary
purchase,' on the present system, I indicated what would be the results; I
only claim credit for some share of common sense: 'Law will have been
severing the occupiers of the soil by an arbitrary process into a pampered
caste, marked off from a disfavoured multitude; and, as a necessary
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account