Ireland -- Politics and government -- 1901-1910; Land tenure -- Ireland
man, and so do the local Nationalist boards; for obvious reasons, both
these orders of men seek to drive the Irish landed gentry from their
homes, and to replace them by dependents in sympathy with them. The demand
has also extended to Ulster, chiefly on account of the harsh distinction
drawn between 'purchasing' and 'non-purchasing' tenants; it is economic
rather than social or political; but the cry for compulsory purchase is
perhaps loudest in parts of the northern province. Its principal champion,
at present, is an enthusiast, sincere, indeed, if without judgment and
insight; but he is sustained by bodies of farmers formidable in numbers at
least.
The sharp and, as I think, the unfair distinction drawn by the present law
between tenant 'purchasers' and tenants still subject to the payment of
rent, has created, it cannot be said too often, the demand for the
compulsory purchase of the Irish land, and for this Lord Salisbury's
Government is largely responsible. But because an Irish peasant, on one
side of a fence, cannot obtain the benefits of land tenure, which his
neighbour, on the other side, has obtained, and may even have a right to
complain, it does not follow that compulsory purchase is a possible, or
aught but a disgraceful policy; other interests and considerations must be
taken into account. Let us first see how compulsory purchase would affect
the financial position of the Three Kingdoms. Great as the prosperity of
the Empire is, the strain on its resources is immense; the expenditure of
the State at home is vast, and on the increase; the war in South Africa,
and the settlement of that huge region, will cost unknown millions; the
reform of our military and even of our naval system, necessary to our
safety, will be a weighty burden for years; every Chancellor of the
Exchequer has declared that fiscal economy, as far as possible, is his
first duty. But what does the compulsory purchase of the Irish land
involve, and what, confessedly, are its essential conditions? Mr.
Gladstone, I have said, asserted, long ago, that the value of the
agricultural area of Ireland was L300,000,000; this estimate, I believe,
is too high; but, in the opinion of competent judges, it cannot be deemed
less than L150,000,000. But the forcible expropriation of the Irish landed
gentry on every principle of civilised law, as, indeed, Sir Michael Hicks
Beach has already insisted, would imply giving them a large additional
bonus; this probably would not be less than L50,000,000; the sum,
therefore, required for compulsory purchase, would, it may be assumed, be
not less than L200,000,000. Now, can any one imagine that the general
taxpayer, in the financial situation in which we are, and shall be for
years, will make himself liable for this colossal charge, equal to the
ransom Germany extorted from France, in order to bribe Irish peasants into
the ownership of their farms, and to effect an agrarian revolution, in
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account