Ireland -- Politics and government -- 1901-1910; Land tenure -- Ireland
to the general interests of the State, it is still more vicious at the
present time; it has been transformed, but, on the whole, transformed for
the worse. As I wrote before, when commenting on the position of affairs
in Ireland, before the Land Act of 1870, a revolution only could have
removed the deep-rooted ills in all that related to the land; a revolution
alone could remove them now. But in the one instance, as in the other, the
evil caused by a revolution would be infinitely greater than the good; a
new agrarian revolution in Ireland would be a curse to her; it is better,
as Burke has remarked, to try to repair even ruins than to blot out every
trace of the edifice. Still, taking it as we find it, can nothing be done
to amend, in some measure, at least, the existing land system? Much of it,
I admit, must be left untouched; the principle of settling rent, through
the agency of the State, false as it is, must continue to work; the
principle of so-called 'land purchase' must, within reasonable limits, be
still given free scope. But something in the nature of reform is, I think,
possible; the discussion of the subject may be of use; I contribute my
mite to it, if with unfeigned diffidence.
In order to find out the truth, and thoroughly to clear the ground, a
Commission, I suggest, ought to be appointed, as important as the Devon
Commission of nearly sixty years ago; it should investigate the Irish Land
Question in all its branches. Its President should be a great English
nobleman--the nation would have confidence in the Duke of Bedford, a
princely and most liberal English landlord; but the judicial element
should be strong in it; English and Irish judges should be among its
members; it should include trained agricultural experts: it should have
representatives of Irish landlords and tenants. It should examine the
Irish land system as this existed before 1870; should review the whole
series of Irish Land Acts, from 1870 to the present time, and inquire into
their results and tendencies; should carefully consider the operation of
the tribunals selected to carry out the new Irish land code, especially as
regards the fixing of 'fair rents,' and that not with respect to their
procedure only, an unjust limit imposed on the Fry Commission, but with
respect to the principles that have been adopted and the methods pursued;
it should deal exhaustively with the subject of so-called 'land purchase,'
and see whether it has not directly led to the demand for compulsory
purchase; it should take evidence as to 'peasant proprietary' and its
creation; and it should make a complete and searching report, with a view
to the legislation it might recommend. And if I am not altogether
mistaken, such a Commission would state, in emphatic language, that the
present Irish land code was ill designed, even if it cannot be now much
changed; that its administration has been attended with grave errors; that
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account