Ireland -- Politics and government -- 1901-1910; Land tenure -- Ireland
The financial relations between Great Britain and Ireland have been a
subject, at intervals of time, no doubt, of strong controversy during a
whole century. I shall not harp on the saying of Johnson to an Irish
friend, 'Avoid a Union with England, she will only rob you;' but, in the
opinion of well-informed Irishmen, the fiscal treatment of Ireland, since
1800-01, strikingly illustrates the significant remark of Burke, 'When any
community is subordinately connected with another, the great danger of the
connection is, the extreme pride and self-complacency of the superior,
which, in all matters of controversy, will probably decide in its own
favour.' There is no reason to impeach the good faith of Pitt and
Castlereagh; but the financial arrangements they made for Ireland, when
the Union became law, were denounced by the most distinguished Irishmen of
the day; these imposed on Ireland an overwhelming burden, and, in fact,
reduced her to the very edge of bankruptcy. A compromise was effected in
1816-17; this has been described as a generous boon to Ireland; but it was
at best a slight relief from injustice; and it weakened securities she had
against fiscal exaction, while it involved her in liabilities which, if
remote, were not the less possible. It is a most significant fact that
Peel, who, as Chief Secretary from 1812 to 1818, was familiar with the
economic state of Ireland, refused, though under the strongest
inducements, to apply to Ireland the fiscal charges extended to her by one
of his brilliant successors; the most sagacious financier of the
nineteenth century played, in this matter, a very different part from the
most impulsive and not the least unscrupulous. In 1853, and from thence in
other years, Mr. Gladstone, in order to carry out a policy distinctly
opposed to many Irish interests, subjected Ireland to a sudden and heavy
load of taxation, exactly at the time when, for the plainest reasons, she
ought to have been exempted from it; from that day to this, Irishmen, who
understand the question, are agreed that this was gross, nay, cruel,
injustice. The whole subject of British and Irish financial relations was
sent by Mr. Gladstone to a Commission in 1893, here following the example
of Mr. Goschen; a careful inquiry was held during many months; the Report
of the Commission was startling and important in the extreme. This
tribunal, mainly composed of eminent English experts, announced, and that
almost with one voice, that Ireland was being enormously overtaxed, and
had been for upwards of forty years; and it plainly intimated that a
remedy for this wrong should be found. No real answer has been made to
this remarkable judgment; the attempts at answers that have been made are
nearly all mere trifling; Lord Salisbury's Government evidently believes
that an answer is not possible; it promised to appoint another Commission
to investigate certain parts of the subject; years have passed, and it has
not performed its promise.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account