Ireland -- Politics and government -- 1901-1910; Land tenure -- Ireland
and resistance to the law, and widely disseminated their pernicious
teaching. In fact, they made themselves agencies of the Land and the
National Leagues; at the same time, in numerous instances, they set the
authority of the Local Government Board at naught.[182]
The system of Irish local government was obviously so defective, so
antiquated, so contrary to the spirit of the age, that several attempts,
we have seen, were made, long ago, to reform it. It has now been
completely transformed on the principles applied to England and Scotland;
the occasion of this transformation was somewhat singular. In 1896
considerable relief was given, in England and Scotland, to the landed
interest by a subvention made by the State, which defrayed half the charge
of the local county rates, the depression of agriculture being so
grievous; the justice of this measure was hardly disputed. But the Report
of the Childers Commission, declaring that Ireland was greatly overtaxed,
and had been for a long series of years, was published about the same
time; the Government, probably because it had made up its mind not to
countenance the report in any way, refused to extend the same relief to
Ireland, although it was as much required--a decision that simply nothing
could warrant. The indignation, however, expressed in Ireland, and the
remonstrances even of the Ministerial Press, angrily as it had challenged
the findings of the report, before long changed the Government's purpose;
it was formally announced, in 1897, that Ireland would obtain the same
boon as Great Britain, and, apparently, as a condition of this, that Irish
local government was to be reformed. The measure of 1898 was the result of
this compromise; the interdependence of two subjects, which have nothing
in common, has made it not easy to interpret; but, as we shall see, its
authors have provided, with skill, against one of the dangers the change
involved, that is, the probability that it might expose the Irish landed
gentry to predatory attacks. Before examining the recent law, I venture to
make a single remark. The question of the alleviation of the charge of
rates, a concession made to Ireland with bad grace, and made to England
and Scotland as a matter of course, has nothing to do with the infinitely
larger question of the excessive taxation imposed on Ireland; relief in
the one case does not imply relief in the other; the two subjects are
altogether distinct. It is essential carefully to keep this in mind, for
attempts are being made to confuse the two questions, and
characteristically to argue that Ireland ought to rest and be thankful,
and not to say a word about her overtaxation, because, forsooth, in common
with England and Scotland, she has received assistance as regards her
local rates.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account