Ireland -- Politics and government -- 1901-1910; Land tenure -- Ireland
This sweeping measure, in my judgment at least, might have been better
framed to carry out its policy. Like much of the legislation of the
Imperial Parliament, it has been fashioned too closely on the English
model; it gives to a poor and backward country, not trained in
self-government, local institutions naturally adapted only to an opulent
and well-ordered country accustomed for centuries to local liberties.
Having regard to the peculiar state of Ireland, it might have made the
powers of local government it conferred larger, but it ought not to have
been as purely democratic as it is; and it ought to have been accompanied
by safeguards it does not possess. I would have been disposed to give the
Irish County Councils a right to take evidence for private Bills on the
spot; this, if transmitted to the Irish Privy Council, and considered by
it, might be made the basis of reports by that body, which could be turned
into Acts of Parliament, by a summary process, thus getting rid of great
and useless expense, and silencing one of the few real arguments in favour
of Home Rule. I would also have allowed the County Councils of different
counties, in matters in which they had a common interest, say, in the
drainage of some of the great Irish rivers, to carry out together public
works of this kind, and to assess and levy rates for the purpose if, on
consideration, this was deemed expedient; at present they have no
authority like this; and such a power would, I think, be for the general
good of Ireland. The County Councils, too, I believe, might be given a
deliberative voice, in cases they have not at present; for example, should
the rate-payers of any county make a demand for sectarian education,
within its area, and declare themselves ready to pay a rate for it, the
County Council should have a right to entertain the project, and to report
on it to the Central Government. And I am convinced that members of the
County Councils ought to have some seats on the Local Government Board,
and on other boards now filled by the Castle bureaucracy; this would
introduce a popular element into these bodies, and, in many ways, would be
of real advantage. On the other hand, in the election and the constitution
of the County and other Councils, democracy has simply been let run riot;
and the resulting evils have already been made manifest. Illiterate
persons ought not to have been qualified to be electors; the single should
not have replaced the cumulative vote, property being thus deprived of its
legitimate weight; above all, as is evident, security should have been
taken that the landed gentry should have a proper representation on the
County Councils. The authority, too, of the Superior Courts over all these
assemblies should have been made more effective and less costly than it is
at present; and that of the Local Government Board should have been better
defined and increased. In all this province the checks possessed by the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account