Ireland -- Politics and government -- 1901-1910; Land tenure -- Ireland
State, and teaching nearly 800,000 pupils; they are supported by model and
training schools, and have a large staff of competent teachers; the
instruction they afford, if not remarkable, is, on the whole, sufficiently
good. It may fairly be said that the National system has been a beneficent
influence of the greatest value; light has shone on a people that once
sate in darkness. The system, however, has become, insensibly, but
greatly, changed; the National Schools have long been, for the most part,
sectarian, that is, composed of Protestant or of Catholic children; the
'mixed' schools, as they are called, are comparatively few. But the main
principle of the system still is in force; the instruction given in the
schools, when the pupils sit together, is strictly secular; and this is
secured by a conscience clause; the Bible cannot be read, in school hours,
even in a Protestant school; no Catholic school can have a Catholic
emblem. The religious instruction given in the schools is hardly what it
ought to be, especially in the case of the Protestant schools; it must be
added that the hope of their founders that they would bridge over the gulf
of discords in Ireland has not been, in the slightest degree, realised.
The Irish are, naturally, a religious people; their history, a long
conflict of races and faiths, has, necessarily, made them intensely
sectarian. The system of education, of which I have traced the outlines,
was certainly not well designed for them; it would have been severely
condemned by Burke, the deepest of thinkers on the affairs of Ireland. And
though the National system has had a real measure of success, it owes
this, in the main, to the immense subvention it receives from the State;
it has little or no support from voluntary aid; an attempt to impose an
education rate on Ireland would be a failure, would not improbably wreck
the system. Nor is this in harmony with genuine Irish sentiment; one of
the most conclusive proofs is that National education has become, to a
great extent, sectarian; the 'Christian Brothers' and the 'Church
Education Society' schools, sustained by voluntary effort alone, and
overweighted in the race by the endowed schools of the State, show how
strong is Irish sectarian feeling. The clergy, too, of the late
Established Church, and a considerable body of their communion, remain
hostile to the National Schools; and though the Catholic priesthood have
made them, to a great extent, their own, and avail themselves of the
advantages they afford, they are hardly in heartfelt sympathy with them.
Nor can it be denied that the conscientious objections to the National
system have real weight; the system, if not irreligious, is, we may say,
neutral; it does not make religion an essential part of school life. It
would, nevertheless, I believe, be exceedingly unwise to disturb a system
which, on the whole, has for many years had excellent results in Ireland.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account