Art, Prehistoric; Folk literature -- History and criticism
The examples which I have given demonstrate beyond cavil that the
process of reading in exists and accounts for the significance of
many geometrical forms; that it is not necessary to assume in each
and every case that geometrical ornament is derived from realistic
representations. Hjalmar Stolpe to whose researches on primitive art we
owe so much had an exaggerated opinion of the importance of realistic
designs, for he believed that every geometric form must have been
derived from a representation. Stephan expresses the same opinion. I
may perhaps illustrate Stolpe’s point of view by one example. Among the
Eskimo of East Greenland is found an eye-shade decoration consisting
of notched pieces of ivory placed side by side. Stolpe explained this
form as a derivation from carvings representing seals, abbreviated due
to the rhythmic repetition of the seal design (fig. 121). However, we
know that the Eskimo when making small blocks of ivory, such as are
used for the manufacture of toggles or other similar objects, cut the
walrus tusk just in this manner, so that through a technical process
they have become familiar with the ornamental form. Therefore it is not
indispensable to assume a realistic origin for the design.
It is interesting to compare the process with which we are dealing with
other ethnic phenomena of similar import. The essential conclusion
drawn from our observations is that the same form may be given
different meanings, that the form is constant, the interpretation
variable, not only tribally but also individually. It can be shown
that this tendency is not by any means confined to art, but that it is
present also in mythology and in ceremonialism, that in these also the
outer form remains, while the accompanying interpretations are widely
different. In the case of mythology we may observe that in the same way
as patterns have a wide distribution, so also motives of myths, or even
whole plots are found over extended areas. For example, the well known
tale of the magic flight, which is one of the most widely distributed
fairy tales, occurs in a number of North American localities. Among
the Eskimo it is given as accounting for the origin of fog; in British
Columbia it is made to account for the origin of certain cannibalistic
ceremonials. Another example is the so-called star husband story, a
tale of two girls who were taken up to the sky by the stars. The story
is widely spread and is told as the explanation of a great variety of
phenomena. The child of one of the women becomes the culture hero and
destroys the monsters infesting the world. Customs, ceremonials, and
prerogatives of clans are explained by this tale, in accordance with
the chief interests of the tribes concerned. The nature myths collected
from all parts of the world by Dähnhardt[73] are full of examples
of this kind: the most diverse features are explained by the same
tales. This shows that it is quite untenable to assume that the tales
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account