Private Sex Advice to Women: For Young Wives and those who Expect to be MarriedArmitage, Robert B.
Science
Private Sex Advice to Women: For Young Wives and those who Expect to be Married
Armitage, Robert B.
Marriage; Sex instruction; Women -- Health and hygiene
In the case of members of the Catholic Church--and these only--there may
seem to be warrant for the objection to Birth Control as "contrary to
religion," it being assumed that the teachings and rules of the Church
constitute the true measure of "religion." To such there is, of course,
only one answer, and that is that if the teaching or practice of Birth
Control methods be held by them to be "contrary to religion" (according
to their definition of "religion") then they have merely to adhere to
the said religious teachings, and to refuse to learn anything about
Birth Control. The matter undoubtedly is one entirely for the exercise
of their own judgment and conscience. There is no desire on the part of
the advocates of Birth Control to insist that such people must limit the
size of their families--or for that matter that there is any "must"
about it for anyone whatsoever.
But we must not lose sight of the fact that the laws and customs of
society in general are not based upon, or bound up with, the teachings
and rules of this particular Church. On the contrary, particularly in
the instance of Marriage and Divorce, many of our customs sanctioned by
our laws permit and sanction things which are not countenanced or
approved of by the Church in question. But just as persons outside of
that Church are in no way bound by the teachings or rules thereof in the
matter of Marriage and Divorce, so are they in no way bound by the
teachings and rules of the said Church concerning the limitation of the
size of families. The Church in question does not regard "civil
marriages" as true marriages at all--yet our laws, and general public
opinion, countenance such marriages; and it is extremely probable that
within a comparatively short time the status of Birth Control will
likewise manifest the same conflict between State and Church. But just
as no Catholic is COMPELLED to accept or practice civil marriage, so no
Catholic will be compelled to accept or practice Birth Control.
Religion is entirely a matter of individual belief and faith, and binds
no one not agreeing with its precepts. There is no union of Church and
State in this country, or in most other modern civilized countries; and
we are not under the jurisdiction of the Church in matters of conscience
or conduct, unless we voluntarily so place ourselves under such
jurisdiction and control. The argument that Birth Control which is based
upon the assertion that it is opposed to the edicts or dogmas of some
particular Church organization, is found to be no true argument for the
reasons given above; and such argument must be dismissed as fallacious
by those who base their judgments and conduct upon the dictates of
science, reason, and common-sense, rather than upon the dogmas or
decrees of any Church organization. The answer to those who urge that
"Birth Control is contrary to the teachings of the Catholic Church" is:
"Well, what of it? if you are not a Catholic!"
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account