The historical case of Pausanias is exactly parallel to that of the
mythological Orestes. Man expects that the dead man will behave as he
would behave were he yet living—pursue him for vengeance; the ghost is an
actual, almost physical reality. It needed a Euripides to see that this
ghost was a purely subjective horror, a disordered conscience. He makes
Menelaos ask the mad Orestes[179]:
‘What dost thou suffer? What disease undoes thee?’
and Orestes makes answer:
‘Conscience, for I am conscious of fell deeds.’
Anthropomorphism is usually regarded as a humane trait in Greek religion;
it is noted as a thing distinguishing their cultus from the animal
worship of less civilized nations. But anthropomorphism, as is clearly
seen in ghost-worship, looks both ways. To be human is not necessarily
to be humane. Man is cruel and implacable, and he makes the ghost after
his own image. Man is also foolish and easily tricked, so he plays tricks
upon the vengeful ghost, cheating him of his real meed of the murderer’s
or kinsman’s blood. Hence the surrogate victims, hence the frequent
substitution stories. Another element enters in. The gods, and specially
the ghost-gods, are conservative; man gets in advance of the gods he
has made, and is ashamed of the rites he once performed with complete
confidence in their rightness. Then he tries by a cheat to reconcile his
new view and his old custom. Religion, which once inspired the best in
him, lags behind, expressing the worst.
Suidas[180] tells a story which curiously expresses this state of
transition, this cheating of the god to save the conscience of the
worshipper. The Greeks had a proverb, Ἔμβαρός εἰμι, ‘I am Embaros,’ which
they used, according to Suidas, of a ‘sharp man with his wits about him,’
and, according to one of the collectors of proverbs, of those who ‘gave
a false impression, i.e. were out of their minds.’ The origin of the
proverb was as follows: There was a sanctuary of Artemis at Munychia. A
bear came into it and was killed by the Athenians. A famine followed,
and the god gave an oracle that the famine should cease if some one
would sacrifice his daughter to the goddess. Embaros was the only man
who promised to do it, on condition that he and his family should have
the priesthood for life. He disguised his daughter and hid her in the
sanctuary, and ‘dressed a goat in a garment and sacrificed it as his
daughter.’ The story is manifestly aetiological, based on a ritual with a
hereditary priesthood, and the sacrifice of a surrogate goat dressed as a
woman.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account