Public health and insurance: American addressesNewsholme, Arthur, Sir
History
Public health and insurance: American addresses
Newsholme, Arthur, Sir
Health insurance -- Great Britain; Public health; Public health -- Great Britain
Other instances will occur to you, illustrating the importance
of a broad outlook in the causation of disease or other forms of
social misery. I will adduce one more. It is well known that infant
mortality is much heavier among the poor than among the well-to-do.
The rule does not hold universally in rural areas, but in towns it
applies almost without exception. And it is assumed by a large school
of social workers that enlightenment of the ignorance of the poor
mother will effectively correct this evil. Such a lop-sided view
ignores many of the elements of the problem of infant mortality.
Think for a moment of the contrast between the working-class mother
of five children living in a small city tenement, and the mother
of an equal number of children in easy circumstances, living in
a residential suburb, and having domestic servants, a nurse, and
a physician always available. The two mothers probably differ but
little in their knowledge of the hygiene of infancy; but the one has
helpers to ensure scrupulous cleanliness, to prevent over-fatigue of
the nursing mother, to detect the first sign of infantile illness and
provide the needed action; while the other mother has to struggle
alone in respect of her infant, without either domestic or nursing
assistance, the struggle being complicated by the fact that the
care of four older children and of her husband is on her shoulders.
Even when there is no actual direct poverty in the working-class
home, the differences thus indicated—supplemented by the inability
of the mother to obtain medical advice for apparently minor
ailments—outweigh enormously the factor of ignorance as a cause of
excessive infant mortality. By all means let instruction be given by
public health nurses or other agencies, and this is most valuable;
but it does not fully meet the needs of the case. There is required
also actual domestic, as well as nursing, assistance in the home of
the overworked working-class mother, especially after the birth of
her infant and when illness attacks any of her children; and unless
the physician realises these elements in the problem, his efforts in
securing the welfare of his patient and in reducing infant mortality
can have but partial success.
The main lessons arising from the foregoing illustrations of medical
and social problems are two: Each evil should be attacked in its
causal relationships; and causation is multiple.
Hence—apart from total prohibition—in attacking alcoholism, the
physician may bless the efforts of tee-total advocates, of those
engaged in reducing the number of saloons, of those securing better
dietetics and cooking, less industrial fatigue, or more satisfactory
domestic sleeping accommodation, and of parents and teachers engaged
in promoting self-control in the young as a habit of life; and he
will call them all in aid of his curative and preventive life work.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account