It will be remembered that at that sitting I first asked him what name the boys had called him, and, after a few partial failures, obviously only due to mismanagement of the table, he replied, 'Pat,' which was quite right. I then asked if he would like to give the name of a brother, and he replied 'Norman,' which I thought was quite wrong. I did not even allow him to finish the last letter. I said he was confused, and had better begin again; after which he amended it to '*Noël,' which I accepted as correct. But it will now be observed that the name 'Norman' was the best he could possibly give, as a kind of comprehensive nickname applicable to almost any brother. And a nickname was an appropriate kind of response, because we had already had the nickname 'Pat,' Furthermore, on subsequent occasions he explained that it was the name by which he had called Lionel; and, through Mrs. Kennedy--if she did not make a mistake--that it was a name he had called Alec by. It is quite possible, however, that he had intended to say 'Lionel' on that occasion, and that she got it wrong. I am not sure how that may be. Again, at a later stage, in a family sitting--no medium present--one of the boys said, "Pat, do you remember 'Norman'?" at which with some excitement, the girls only touching the table, he spelt out 'HOCKEY'; thus completing the whole incident. The most evidential portions, however, are those obtained when nobody present understood what was being said--namely, first, the spelling of the name 'Norman' when those present thought that it was all a mistake after the first two letters; and secondly, the explanation to Mrs. Kennedy that it was a name by which he had called one of his brothers, showing that it was originally given by no accident, but with intention. As to the name 'Pat' (p. 140), I extract the following from a diary of Noël, as evidence that it was very much Raymond's nickname; but of course we knew it:-- 1914 "Sept. 9. Pat goes to L'pool _re_ Commission. " 10. Pat gets commission in 3rd South Lanc's. " 14. Pat collecting kit. We inspect revolvers. " 18. Pat comes up to Harborne for some rifle practice. Does not find it too easy. " 19. I become member of Harborne Rifle Club. " 20. Pat shoots again. Sept. 23. Pat leaves for L'pool to start his training at Great Crosby. I give up commission-idea for the present. Oct. 17. Pat comes home to welcome Parents back from Australia. " 20. Pat returns to L'pool." _Note on the name 'Mitchell' (added later)_ It can be remembered that, when asked on 28 September for the name of an officer, Raymond spelt out MITCHELL, and indicated decisively that the word AEROPLANE was connected with him; he also assented to the idea that he was one whom the family didn't know, and that so it would be better as evidence (pp. 141, 142).