Recent discussions on the abolition of patents for inventions in the United Kingdom, France, Germany, and the Netherlands : $b Evidence, speeches, and papers in its favour
General
Recent discussions on the abolition of patents for inventions in the United Kingdom, France, Germany, and the Netherlands : $b Evidence, speeches, and papers in its favour
Patents
In the history of the Netherlands economy, the 22nd June, 1869, will be
long remembered. Whatever shall be the decision of the First Chamber,
the fact of the Law [Bill] having passed the Second Chamber by 48 yeas
against 8 noes is a highly gratifying occurrence.
The chief feature in the opposition on the part of the Conservatives was
the able speeches made by their leader, M. Heemskerk, in order to prove
that invention confers a right of property. Without going into the merits
of the case, we cannot help recording that, in the opinion of those that
side with M. H., it must be a suggestive circumstance that, despite
all the earnest pleading of the honourable gentleman, 48 out of 57
representatives, of men of the highest moral and intellectual standing,
did vote for abolition, and still did not intend despoiling anybody of
his own.
Invention is the effusion of thought, and just as thought cannot but be
free, so invention must be the same.
We hope that the Netherlands will not long remain alone in this instance.
At any rate, we may be proud of the overwhelming majority of men able to
understand the real means of progress.
EXTRACT FROM AN OBLIGING PRIVATE LETTER.
Amsterdam, June 28, 1869.
... In some respects, the rather powerful arguments of the members
who were favourable to the continuance of the system of Patents—and
who contended that an inventor, the same as an author, has a right
to protection of his individual mind-work—were defeated, principally
by the pretty general opinion of the majority that it would be
next to impossible to adopt any new Law on Patents efficient to
protect one inventor without at the same time injuring not only some
brother-inventor, but also the public at large.
FROM THE “FRANKFORT JOURNAL,” JULY 21.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account