Recollections and impressions of James A. McNeill WhistlerEddy, Arthur Jerome
General
Recollections and impressions of James A. McNeill Whistler
Eddy, Arthur Jerome
Painters -- United States -- 19th century -- Biography; Whistler, James McNeill, 1834-1903
“It is, indeed, by this that the works of Turner are peculiarly
distinguished from those of all other colorists,--by the dazzling
intensity, namely, of the light which he sheds through every hue,
and which, far more than their brilliant color, is the real source
of their overpowering effect upon the eye, an effect so
_reasonably_ made the subject of perpetual animadversion, as if the
sun which they represent were a quiet, and subdued, and gentle, and
manageable luminary, and never dazzled anybody, under any
circumstances whatsoever. I am fond of standing by a bright Turner
in the Academy, to listen to the unintentional compliments of the
crowd,--‘What a glaring thing!’ ‘I declare I can’t look at it!’
‘Don’t it hurt your eyes?’--expressed as if they were in the
constant habit of looking the sun full in the face with the most
perfect comfort and entire facility of vision. It is curious after
hearing people malign some of Turner’s noble passages of light to
pass to some really ungrammatical and false pictures of the old
masters in which we have color given _without_ light.”[40]
“What I am next about to say with respect to Turner’s color I
should wish to be received with caution, as it admits of dispute.
I think that the first approach to viciousness of color in any
master is commonly indicated chiefly by a prevalence of purple and
an absence of yellow. I think nature mixes yellow with almost every
one of her hues, never, or very rarely, using red without it, but
frequently using yellow with scarcely any red; and I believe it
will be in consequence found that her favorite opposition, that
which generally characterizes and gives tone to her color, is
yellow and black, passing, as it retires, into white and blue. It
is beyond dispute that the great fundamental opposition of Rubens
is yellow and black, and that on this, concentrated in one part of
the picture and modified in various grays throughout, chiefly
depend the tones of all his finest works. And in Titian, though
there is a far greater tendency to the purple than in Rubens, I
believe no red is ever mixed with the pure blue, or glazed over it,
which has not in it a modifying quantity of yellow. At all events,
I am nearly certain that whatever rich and pure purples are
introduced locally by the great colorists nothing is so destructive
of all fine color as the slightest tendency to purple in general
tone; and I am equally certain that Turner is distinguished from
all the vicious colorists of the present day by the foundation of
all his tones being black, yellow, and the intermediate grays,
while the tendency of our common glare-seekers is invariably to
pure, cold, impossible purples.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account