Recollections and impressions of James A. McNeill WhistlerEddy, Arthur Jerome
General
Recollections and impressions of James A. McNeill Whistler
Eddy, Arthur Jerome
Painters -- United States -- 19th century -- Biography; Whistler, James McNeill, 1834-1903
Whistler was of the choice few who would never speak seriously of his
serious pursuits in general conversation. At those very moments when he
seemed to be saying most about art and artists he was in reality saying
least of what he really thought. When he talked most of himself he said
nothing that he really felt. It was almost impossible to draw from him a
serious opinion concerning a picture or a painter. Though he might rail
by the hour against this man or that, if the mood seized him, it all
meant nothing.
In his studio, when at work, opinions and appreciations worth
remembering would drop from his lips; but he rarely committed himself;
not because his convictions were not clear, but because he seldom
thought it worth while.
* * * * *
Once he was dining with quite a distinguished company. The
conversation--possibly as tribute to the presence of so noted an
artist--turned upon art, and finally upon a notorious picture, called
“Nana,” of a naked woman on a couch, that was quite a sensation in
London. It has been seen on this side.
Loud were the expressions of approval. Whistler remained silent.
“What do you think of ‘Nana,’ Mr. Whistler?” asked the
distinguished lady at his right.
“Is it not wonderful?--so life-like,” exclaimed the distinguished
lady at his left.
But Whistler, apparently spellbound by the bird before him, was
silent.
“But, Mr. Whistler, you have not told us what _you_ think about
‘Nana,’” said the distinguished lady opposite.
At bay at last, he said:
“Really, madam, you know, it is quite--presumptious--quite, for one
who--who is simply, as one might say, a painter, and therefore--you
know--not entitled to opinions--to express himself in the presence
of so--so many distinguished connoisseurs; but--since you demand my
opinion--as a highwayman would a purse--I yield to superior
strength and say--with all deference--that ‘Nana’ is--trash.”
“Oh!”
“Oh, Mr. Whistler.”
“But have you seen it?”
“No.”
“Then, how can you say it is trash?”
“It must be--it--is so--popular.”
“Will you go to see it?”
“That is not necessary.”
“But I want you to go with me to-morrow to see ‘Nana.’” And the
charming lady on his right insisted so imperiously that he should
go with her and several of the company who wished to be of the
party, that he yielded, saying, however:
“On one condition.”
“What is it?”
“That you will go with me afterward, to the National Gallery and
see some pictures I am sure you have never seen.”
“Some new ones?”
“To you--yes.”
It was agreed; and the following day Whistler with several of the
party paid each a shilling to see “Nana” stretched at ease under a
strong light at the far end of a dark room. It might have been a
painting or “Nana” herself, the realism was so gross.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account