Reminiscences of Sixty Years in Public Affairs, Vol. 2Boutwell, George S. (George Sewall)
History
Reminiscences of Sixty Years in Public Affairs, Vol. 2
Boutwell, George S. (George Sewall)
Boutwell, George S. (George Sewall), 1818-1905; United States -- Politics and government
When General Lee was pressed by Senator Howard as to the feeling in the
South in regard to the National Government, he said: "I believe that
they will perform all the duties that they are required to perform. I
think that is the general feeling. . . . I do not know that there is
any deep-seated dislike. I think it is probable that there may be
some animosity still existing among some of the people of the South.
. . . They were disappointed at the result of the war."
General Lee was of the opinion that a Southern jury would not find an
accused guilty of treason for participation in the war. Indeed his
doctrine of State Rights excused the citizen and placed the sole
responsibility on the State. Of the common sentiment in the South he
said: "So far as I know, they will look upon the action of the State,
in withdrawing itself from the government of the United States, as
carrying the individuals of the State along with it; that the State
was responsible for the act, not the individual." This was the
framework of his own defence. Speaking of the advocates of secession,
he said: "The ordinance of secession, or those acts of a State which
recognized a condition of war between the State and the General
Government, stood as their justification for their bearing arms against
the Government of the United States. They considered the act of the
State as legitimate. That they were merely using the reserved right,
which they had a right to do."
From these views General Lee was led to a specific statement of his
own position:
Question: "State, if you please, what your own personal views on that
question were?"
Answer: "That was my view; that the act of Virginia in withdrawing
herself from the United States carried me along as a citizen of
Virginia, and that her laws and her acts were binding on me.'
Question: "And that you felt to be your justification in taking the
course you did?"
Answer: "Yes, sir."
In the course of the examination General Lee expressed the opinion that
the "trouble was brought about by the politicians of the country."
General Lee disclaimed all responsibility for the care and treatment of
prisoners of war. He had always favored a free exchange of prisoners,
knowing that the proper means for the care and comfort of prisoners
could not be furnished in the Confederacy. He thought that the
hardships and neglects had been exaggerated. As to himself, he had
never had any control over prisoners, except as they were captured on
the field of battle. He sent his prisoners to Richmond where they came
under the command of the provost-marshal-general. His orders to
surgeons on the field were to treat all the wounded alike.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account