Representative British Orations Volume 2 (of 4): With Introductions and Explanatory Notes
History
Representative British Orations Volume 2 (of 4): With Introductions and Explanatory Notes
Speeches, addresses, etc., English
[Mr. Mackintosh then proceeds to a somewhat minute analysis of
the publications of Peltier for the purpose of showing: first,
that it was highly probable that the articles complained of
were not written by Peltier; secondly, that if written by him,
they purported to be not his own sentiments but those more
or less prevalent at Paris; thirdly, that the publications
were not untrue representations; fourthly, that there was no
evidence of any thing more nearly approaching to malice than
a justifiable indignation; and, fifthly, that the passages
complained of were aimed not so much at Napoleon as at others.
This analysis, though very ingenious, is of no interest except
from its bearing on the verdict, and is therefore here omitted.
After concluding his discussion of the evidence, the advocate
proceeded.]
Here, gentlemen, I think I might stop, if I had only to consider the
defence of Mr. Peltier. I trust that you are already convinced of his
innocence. I fear I have exhausted your patience, as I am sure I have
very nearly exhausted my own strength. But so much seems to me to
depend on your verdict, that I can not forbear from laying before you
some considerations of a more general nature.
Believing, as I do, that we are on the eve of a great struggle; that
this is only the first battle between reason and power; that you
have now in your hands, committed to your trust, the only remains of
free discussion in Europe, now confined to this kingdom—addressing
you, therefore, as the guardians of the most important interests of
mankind; convinced that the unfettered exercise of reason depends more
on your present verdict than on any other that was ever delivered by
a jury, I can not conclude without bringing before you the sentiments
and examples of our ancestors in some of those awful and perilous
situations by which divine Providence has in former ages tried the
virtue of the English nation. We are fallen upon times in which it
behooves us to strengthen our spirits by the contemplation of great
examples of constancy. Let us seek for them in the annals of our
forefathers.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account