Research methods in ecologyClements, Frederic E. (Frederic Edward)
Science
Research methods in ecology
Clements, Frederic E. (Frederic Edward)
Plant ecology; Plant ecology -- Methodology
=183. Scope.= The primary task of experimental evolution is the detailed
study, under measured conditions, of the origin of new forms in nature.
As a department of botanical research that is as yet unformed, it has
little concern with the host of hypotheses and theories which rest
merely upon general observation and conjecture. A few of these
constitute good working hypotheses or serve to indicate possible points
of attack, but the vast majority are worthless impedimenta which should
be thrown away at the start. It is the general practice to speak of
evolution as founded upon a solid basis of incontestible facts, but a
cursory examination of the evidence shows that it is drawn, almost
without exception, from observation alone, and has in consequence
suffered severely from interpretation. With the exception of De Vries’s
work on mutation, sustained and accurate investigation of the evolution
of plants has been lacking. As a result, botanical research has been
built high upon an insecure foundation, nearly every stone of which must
be carefully tested before it can be left permanently in place. In a
field so vast and important as evolution, experiment should far outrun
induction, and deduction should enter only when it can show the way to a
working hypothesis of real merit. The great value of De Vries’s study of
mutation as an example of the proper experimental study of evolution has
been seriously reduced by the fact that the “mutation theory” has
carried induction far beyond the warrant afforded by experiment. The
investigator who plans to make a serious study by experiment of the
origin of new plant forms should rest secure in the conviction that the
most rapid and certain progress can be made only by the accumulation of
a large number of unimpeachable facts, obtained by the most exact
methods of experimental study.
The general application of field experiment to evolution will render the
current methods of recognizing species quite useless. It will become
imperative to establish an experimental test for forms and species, and
to apply this test critically to every “new species.” Descriptive
botany, as practiced at present, will fall into disuse, as scientific
standards come to prevail, and in its place will appear a real science
of taxonomy. In the latter the criteria upon which species are based
will be obtained solely by experiment.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account