Of a _DISPUTE_ upon XIV. of his _Proposals_ held and debated betwixt him, the said _Roger Williams_, on the one part, and _John Stubs_, _William Edmundson_ and _John Burnyeat_ on the other. At _Providence_ and _Newport_ in _Rode-Island_, in the Year 1672. IN which his _Cavils_ are Refuted, & his _Reflections_ Reproved. In Two Parts. AS ALSO, An _ANSWER_ to _R. W’s APPENDIX_, &c. WITH A _POST-SCRIPT_ Confuting his Blasphemous Assertions, _viz._ _Of the Blood of_ Christ, _that was Shed, its being_ Corruptible _and_ Corrupted; _and that_ Salvation _was by a Man, that was_ Corruptible, &_c._ Where-unto is added a _CATALOGUE_ of his _Railery_, _Lies_, _Scorn_ & _Blasphemies_: And His _TEMPORIZING SPIRIT_ made manifest. Also, The _LETTERS_ of _W. Coddington_ of _Rode-Island_, and _R. Scot_ of _Providence_ in _New-England_ concerning _R.W._ And _Lastly_, Some _TESTIMONIES_ of _Antient_ & _Modern Authors_ concerning the _LIGHT_, _SCRIPTURES_, _RULE_ &, the _SOUL_ of _Man_. By _GEORGE FOX_ and _JOHN BURNYEAT_. Printed in the Year MDC. LXXIX. [Illustration: Rhode Island Historical Society Museum] [Illustration: Apple Tree Root from the Grave of Roger Williams] [Illustration: Grave of Roger Williams] Roger Williams for many years had a trading-place, where he did business with the Indians. This store was near the present village of Wickford. His profits, he tells us, were five hundred dollars a year. The foundations of this old building are still intact, with a new superstructure over them. Late in life he made monthly preaching visits to this place. When too old to do this, he planned the publication of his sermons for the natives. Roger Williams was the original missionary to the North American Indians, antedating the illustrious Eliot by thirteen years. Williams’ Indian Bible is in the John Hay Library, Providence, R. I. [Illustration: New Testament Title-page of Roger Williams’ Indian Bible] WUSKU WUTTESTAMENTUM NULLORDUMUN JESUS CHRIST Nuppoquohwussuaeneumun. [Illustration] _CAMBRIDGE_: Printed by _Samuel Green_ and _Marmaduke Johnson_, MDCLXI. [Illustration: Indian Bible Used by Roger Williams, the Pioneer Missionary to the American Indians] THE HOLY BIBLE: CONTAINING THE OLD TESTAMENT AND THE _NEW_. Translated into the