Roman Stoicism: being lectures on the history of the Stoic philosophy with special reference to its development within the Roman EmpireArnold, Edward Vernon
Religion
Roman Stoicism: being lectures on the history of the Stoic philosophy with special reference to its development within the Roman Empire
Arnold, Edward Vernon
Stoics
The bronze is the first cause of a statue; for it could never
have been made, had there not been stuff to be cast or wrought
into shape. The second cause is the sculptor; for the bronze
could never have been brought into the shape of a statue without
the artist’s touch. The third cause is the design; for the
statue would not be called the ‘javelin-man’ or the ‘crowned
king’ had not such a design been impressed upon it.
There is besides a fourth cause, the purpose. What is purpose?
It is that which induced the sculptor to undertake the work, the
aim that he had in view. It may have been money, if he intended
to sell it; or glory, if he wished to make himself a name; or
religious feeling, if he proposed to present it to a temple. That
for the sake of which a thing is done is therefore also a cause;
for you cannot think it right in making up a list of causes to
omit something, apart from which the thing would never have been
made.
Thus Aristotle postulates a multiplicity of causes; but we
maintain that the list is either too long or too short.
If we hold that everything, apart from which the thing would
never have been made, is a cause of its making, then the list is
too short. We ought to reckon time as a cause, for nothing can be
made without time. We ought to reckon space as a cause; for if
there is no room for a thing to be made, it will certainly not
be made. Movement too should be placed in the list; for without
movement nothing can be produced or destroyed; without movement
there can be neither art nor change.
We Stoics look for a first and general cause. Such a cause must
be single, for the stuff of the universe is single. We ask what
that cause is, and reply that it is the creative reason, the
deity. The various causes in the list that has been made are
not a series of independent causes, but are all variations of a
single cause, namely ‘the maker[41].’
[Sidenote: Causation and free-will.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account