Schools of Gaul in the last century of the Western Empire : $b A study of pagan and Christian education in the last century of the Western empireHaarhoff, T. J. (Theodore Johannes)
History
Schools of Gaul in the last century of the Western Empire : $b A study of pagan and Christian education in the last century of the Western empire
Haarhoff, T. J. (Theodore Johannes)
Education, Ancient -- France; Gaul -- History -- 58 B.C.-511 A.D.
This is the point, ‘Greek _or_ Roman’. Educational experience has shown
that a school-system must be elastic and accommodate itself to the
psychology and the needs of the child. Wherever there have been bilingual
countries the problem has arisen. What is educationally the soundest
principle of manipulating the language question? At first it was thought
that the language of the higher culture should be enforced on all. It
would save time and expense and trouble; moreover (so men argued), it
would be in the interest of the child whose mother-tongue was thus
disregarded, for he would have so much more time to learn the language
of the ‘superior culture’. Your own language, they told the other party,
you know already and your children need not spend time on it at school.
Better, therefore, to have a uniform language throughout.
Now such a course (looking at it from the educational point of view)
has been proved over and over again to be utterly unsound. The verdict
of history has been to uphold, even at the cost of money and time and
trouble, the principle of mother-tongue instruction. You must, as
Augustine implied, start with what is natural to the child. If you begin
with what is strange and has no connexion with his thoughts and speech,
you are merely delaying his progress. You will, no doubt, develop his
memory, but his thought will remain untouched. Inspectors in the schools
of South Africa have reported repeatedly the case of Dutch children
who have been started on English, that they read and spell perfectly,
but are quite unable to explain the meaning of an English sentence.
The consequence is that they take twice as long to pass the elementary
standards as they normally would. The same has been found in Quebec and
in India and Burma. Teachers and missionaries everywhere have discovered
that the mother-tongue principle is the only fruitful one. They have
found that where it is applied progress follows in an unexpected way.
Once the child has learned to use, to analyse, to understand his own
language, once his thought has been set going, he will learn the second
language more quickly than the child who started with the second
language. He is therefore ahead in three respects: his thought has been
stimulated, he has learned his own language, he has learned another
language, whereas the other has not been induced to think, knows his own
language superficially and the second language imperfectly. This can be
substantiated by many cases from the experience of teachers in bilingual
countries.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account