Schools of Hellas: An Essay on the Practice and Theory of Ancient Greek Education from 600 to 300 B. C.Freeman, Kenneth J. (Kenneth John)
History
Schools of Hellas: An Essay on the Practice and Theory of Ancient Greek Education from 600 to 300 B. C.
Freeman, Kenneth J. (Kenneth John)
Education, Greek
But the poet not only poses himself: he makes his audience, his
reader, his performer pose. The boy who recites the dying speech of
Aias in Sophocles’ play is posing as Aias, pretending to be Aias, and
adopting the tone and the traits of Aias. The boy who dances in the
dithyramb _Semelé_ is trying to enter into Semelé’s feelings and
moods, being helped by the music and the gestures and the words.[713]
Such posing, if begun in early years, will invade the character and
change it: the boy will become like the personages whom he is
accustomed to act. Hence Plato lays down strict laws dealing with the
recitations and dances of the young.[714] “If they speak in character,
it must only be in the character of those who are, what they
themselves must be when they are grown up, brave, temperate, pious
gentlemen. They must have no skill in taking unsuitable characters,
lest from their dramatic representation of what is vulgar and base
they become infected with the reality of vulgarity and baseness. For
imitation, if begun in early years and carried far, sinks into a boy’s
habits and nature, and influences his voice, his gestures, and his
ideas.… So boys must not be allowed to take the character of a woman,
young or old, abusing her husband or blaspheming against the gods or
uttering lamentations,――certainly not of a woman in sickness or in
love or in pangs; nor the character of slaves performing slavish
duties; nor of bad men, cowards, insulting or mocking one another,
using foul language, drunk or sober; nor yet of madmen.”[715] It will
be seen that this will exclude much of Hellenic drama, especially of
the plays of Euripides and Aristophanes. Comedy, according to Plato,
should only be acted by foreigners, and should serve as an awful
warning of everything that a gentleman ought not to do. The new music
is subjected to similar rules. “Boys must not imitate blacksmiths at
the forge, or craftsmen occupied in any trade, or sailors rowing, or
boatswains giving them orders, or anything of the sort; nor yet horses
neighing, or bulls roaring, or the noise of rivers or the sea or
thunder or wind or hail or chariot-wheels or pulleys or trumpets or
flutes or pipes …; nor the sounds made by dogs and sheep and birds.”
So the proper style of poetry for educational purposes will be mostly
narrative, with occasional dramatisation of virtuous men. To accompany
this simplified and purified poetry only the Dorian and Phrygian
“harmonies” will be required: all the others may be rejected. Simple
instruments alone will be wanted: many-stringed lyres and the flute
can be banished. The seven-stringed lyre and the shepherd’s pipe will
be left.
Plato finds it too difficult to carry these principles into rhythm,
since he is not an expert in the subject. But he thinks that the
metres could be regulated in accordance with his canons; the expert
Damon declared that some had a demoralising tendency.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account