Science and Medieval Thought: The Harveian Oration Delivered Before the Royal College of Physicians, October 18, 1900Allbutt, T. Clifford (Thomas Clifford)
Philosophy
Science and Medieval Thought: The Harveian Oration Delivered Before the Royal College of Physicians, October 18, 1900
Allbutt, T. Clifford (Thomas Clifford)
Philosophy, Medieval
Brewer for the Master of the Rolls.” We know also that more than one
scholar of the 11-12th centuries travelled in the East, though, as Dr
Daremberg says, travellers to the East were more apt to bring back
false relics than genuine manuscripts. There was a small Greek
community and a Greek monastery at Auriol, near the old colony of
Marseilles. Still, for lack of masters and materials, Greek then was a
very rare accomplishment; and it is manifest, from much internal
evidence, that Albert had no Greek; though he certainly possessed
Greco-latin translations of some few Aristotelian treatises by other
hands, of the _De anima_ and of the Physics for example, whence he
makes quotations without interspersion of Arabic titles, proper names,
nouns and terms, such as he rather helplessly reproduces in his
rendering of the ninth book of the _De cælo_ and elsewhere. We know
from other sources that a few treatises, such as the _De anima_, and
the first two books of the Ethics, existed in Greco-latin rendering
before the Arab-latin versions of Michael Scot and others (1220-1225).
In later life Albert had the assistance of Aquinas to whom we have
attributed some knowledge of Greek; for we find Aquinas, with the
countenance of Urban the Fourth, not only searching Europe for Greek
manuscripts, sending emissaries to Spain to make versions for him, and
supervising the preparation of translations directly into Latin, but
also personally comparing the Latin translations with the Greek texts
of the Ethics and Politics, and recording variants; variants which
Albert copied from his disciple. (It may be worthy of remark that even
so late as 1586 there were no Greek types in Oxford, and that in 1599
Casaubon (Life by Pattison) could find no compositors for Greek in
Lyons.) The great debt of the West to the Arabs was a new enthusiasm
for learning, and for the “Princeps philosophorum”; not their
travestied texts and unwieldy commentaries, which Roger Bacon,
probably perceiving that his contemporaries swore by the Arab rather
than by the Greek, wished he could burn.
[59] To wonder why Roger Bacon became a clerk and a Franciscan is to
look upon the thirteenth century with the eyes of the nineteenth. The
vision of St Francis had not grown dim; the strange beauty of his life
held men captive still, and his cheerful natural religion still
animated his disciples. None could have said more truly than St
Francis
“While others fish with craft for great opinion,
I with great truth catch mere simplicity.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account