Scientific American, September 29, 1883 Supplement. No. 404Various
Science
Scientific American, September 29, 1883 Supplement. No. 404
Various
Science -- Periodicals
The first source of fallacy in the arguments referred to lies in the
misinterpretation of the term "sewer gas," connecting it with sewers in
particular instead of with sewage in general. Thus, I find it stated
that typhoid is "more prevalent in the suburbs and surrounding country
than in the cities subjected to the contamination of sewer gas;" that
diphtheria and scarlatina occur most fatally "in the country, where
sewer gas is wanting;" and that in Philadelphia the extension of the
sewage system into the rural sections has diminished the sickness
from fever. Now the facts on which most sanitarians lay great stress
are, that unsewered rural districts are more exposed to danger from
fermenting filth than cities, that the ineffable atrocities of leaching
cesspools and privy-vaults (those perversions of barbarism to which
the American rustic clings as to his most precious birthright) do
infinitely more to poison air, and soil, and water than all the
blunders of city engineers and plumbers combined; and that, granting
the worst that can be said of some city sewers which shall be nameless,
even a bad sewer is better than none at all--which is merely equivalent
to saying that it is better to carry away as much of one's sewage as
possible than to keep the whole of it on the premises to decompose
under one's nose. And the peril from this fount and origin of evil
is augmented a hundredfold where the mania for "modern improvements"
has invaded rural households. Long before sewers are thought of--even
before the importation of the agonizing pianoforte--the suburban
housewife insists on having a bath-room, including that sum and
substance of vileness, a pan water-closet on the bedchamber floor, and
a kitchen sink and "stationary tubs" down stairs; and these fixtures,
commonly constructed in the cheapest and nastiest manner, are connected
with an unventilated cesspool, serving as so many inlets to insure
the constant pollution of the house atmosphere with the gases of
decomposition. Then, in an uncemented basement a "portable furnace"
is arranged to transport to the upper rooms not only the cellar-air,
but the freely indrawn "ground atmosphere," laden with noxious vapors
from the soil-soakage of cesspools or privies. It is not saying too
much to affirm that for every one channel of filth-poisoning in a
paved and sewered city there are at least three in the average village
settlement, and if the evidence of insanitary conditions be found in
"not more than one house out of five," it is because, unfortunately,
very few physicians in this country have cared to learn how to look
for it--familiarity with the doses of drugs and the results of disease
being regarded in most of our medical schools as vastly more important
than _rerum cognoscere causas_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account