Second Shetland Truck System ReportGuthrie, William
History
Second Shetland Truck System Report
Guthrie, William
Labor law -- Truck system -- History -- England; Shetland (Scotland) -- History
1997. Do you know whether they prefer to sell to strangers, or to
merchants in town?-Sometimes they require money, and at other
times they require goods as well as money; and they would then
just as well have the goods as the money.
1998. But if they want the money, can they not have it from the
merchants if they ask for it?-I always got it when I asked it. For
any others, I cannot say.
1999. Do you dress goods for any of the merchants?-No.
2000. Only for the knitters?-Yes.
2001. You are never employed by the merchants at all?-No.
2002. Can you tell me; why there is not a system of paying always
in money for the hosiery?-Because it has not been a customary
thing, and they never ask it.
2003. Would it not be just as convenient for all parties to pay in
money?-I don't think it. I think we may just as well have the
goods.
2004. But if you had the money, it would be better for the knitters,
would it not; because they could buy what goods they wanted?
They might have to hand the money back across the counter, but
they would be able to make their own bargain for what they
bought?-Yes; but they would get a less price for their shawls.
2005. How do you know that?-It is so stated.
2006. Who states it?-They generally say that if they get money,
they will not get so much as in goods.
2007. Do you mean that the merchants say that?-Yes; when we
sell shawls for money, they say they will not give so much for
them in money as in goods.
2008. Who has told you that?-The merchants.
2009. Has that often been said to you?-Not often; but it has been
said.
2011. Who has said it?-Mr. Sinclair: I sold shawl to him last
night.
2012. And he told you last night that he would give you more in
goods for it than he would give in money?-Yes, than he could
give in money.
2013. What was the price of that shawl?-I got 15s. for it.
2014. Did you take that in goods?-Yes.
2015. Or in a line?-In goods.
2016. In goods that you took away at the time?-Yes.
2017. What would you have got if you had sold your shawl for
money?-I cannot exactly say. He did not particularize that.
2018. You did not go into particulars, because you wanted the
goods?-Yes.
2019. Do you sometimes sell goods that you get from the
merchants?-No; for I always require them for myself.
2020. Is it the practice for some of the knitters to sell the goods
they get?-I cannot say; I never saw it done.
2021. You never bought any goods from a knitter which she had
got in that way?-No, never.
2022. You are always paid in cash for your own dressing?-Yes.
2023. Do you think the knitters generally would be content with
lower prices if they got paid in cash?-I cannot speak for any one
but myself.
2024. You don't know the feelings of the girls deal with you from
the town?-I do not.
2025. Do you know how most of these girls are provided with their
food?-I cannot say. Occasionally the girls don't require money.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account