Selected papers on hysteria and other psychoneurosesFreud, Sigmund
Science
Selected papers on hysteria and other psychoneuroses
Freud, Sigmund
Hysteria; Neuroses; Psychoanalysis
Miss Rosalia H., twenty-three years old, who for a number of years made
great effort to educate herself as a singer, complained that her
beautiful voice did not obey her in certain notes. There appeared
choking and tightening sensations in the throat so that the tones
sounded strained, and her teacher could therefore not allow her to
appear in public. Although this imperfection affected only her middle
notes it could not be explained to be due to a defect of her vocal
organs, for at times this disturbance was absent and her teacher was
very pleased with her, but at other times the slightest excitement,
seemingly without any provocation, evoked the choking sensation, and
prevented free expansion of the voice. It was not difficult to recognize
in this annoying sensation an hysterical conversion. Whether there
really appeared a contracture of certain muscles of the vocal chords I
have not verified.[21] In the hypnotic analysis which I undertook with
this girl I found out the following concerning her vicissitudes and her
ailments occasioned through them. She became an orphan at an early age
and was brought up at the house of an aunt who had many children of her
own, and she thus shared the life of a most unfortunate family. The
husband of this aunt, seemingly a pathological personality, abused his
wife and children in the most brutal manner and especially pained her by
his sexual preference for the servant girl in the house. This became
even more obnoxious as the children grew older. When the aunt died
Rosalia became the protectress of the orphaned children who were
harassed by their father. She took her duties seriously, fought through
all conflicts and had to exert her greatest efforts to suppress the
manifestations of her contempt for her uncle. It was then that the
choking sensation in her throat originated. Whenever she was compelled
to swallow an affront, whenever she had to remain silent on hearing a
provoking accusation she perceived a scratching in her throat, the
tightening and failure of her voice, in brief she had all the localized
sensations in her larynx and pharynx which now disturbed her in singing.
It was conceivable that she sought the possibility of making herself
independent in order to escape the excitement and painful impressions
which were daily occurrences in her uncle’s house. An efficient music
teacher took an unselfish interest in her, assuring her that her voice
entitled her to choose the profession of singing. She began secretly to
take lessons of him and because she often went for her lessons with the
choking sensation in her throat following some violent scene in the
house, a connection was formed between the singing and the hysterical
paresthesia for which a way was prepared by the sensitiveness of the
organ during singing. The apparatus of which she should have had free
control was filled with the remnants of innervation after those numerous
scenes of repressed excitement. Since then she has left the house of her
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account