Of course there is this difference between the grower of plants or
animals and the grower of children; the former is dealing with his
subject as a superior power with a force which will always remain
subject to his, while the latter is dealing with a force which is bound
to become his equal, and taking it in the long and large sense, bound
ultimately to supersede him. The fear of "the footfalls of the young
generation" is in his ears, whether he is aware of it or not, and he
instinctively does what every living thing seeks to do; viz., to
preserve his power. Since he cannot remain forever the superior, the
dictator, he endeavors to put a definite mould upon that power which he
must share--to have the child learn what he has learned, as he has
learned it, and to the same end that he has learned it.
The grower of flowers, or fruits, or vegetables, or the raiser of
animals, secure in his forever indisputable superiority, has nothing to
fear when he inquires into the ways of his subjects; he will never
think: "But if I heed such and such manifestation of the flower's or the
animal's desire or repulsion, it will develop certain tendencies as a
result, which will eventually overturn me and mine, and all that I
believe in and labor to preserve." The grower of children is perpetually
beset by this fear. He must not listen to a child's complaint against
the school: it breaks down the mutual relation of authority and
obedience; it destroys the faith of the child that his olders know
better than he; it sets up little centers of future rebellion in the
brain of every child affected by the example. No: complaint as to the
wisdom of the system must be discouraged, ignored, frowned down, crushed
by superior dignity; if necessary, punished. The very best answer a
child ever gets to its legitimate inquiry, "Why do I have to learn such
and such a thing?" is, "Wait till you get older, and you will understand
it all. Just now you are a little too young to understand the
reasons."--(In ninety-nine cases out of a hundred the answerer got the
same reply to his own question twenty years before; and he has never
found out since, either). "Do as we tell you to, now," say the teachers,
"and be sure that we are instructing you for your good. The explanations
will become clear to you some time." And the child smothers his
complaint, cramps his poor little body to the best of his ability, and
continues to repeat definitions which mean nothing to him but strings of
long words, and rules which to him are simply torture--apparatus
invented by his "natural enemies" to plague children.--I recall quite
distinctly the bitter resentment I felt toward the inverted divisor. The
formula was easy enough to remember: "Invert the terms of the divisor
and proceed as in multiplication of fractions." I memorized it in less
than a minute, and followed the prescription, and got my examples,
correct. But "Oh, how, how was the miracle accomplished? Why should a
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account