Sex variant women in literature : $b A historical and quantitative surveyFoster, Jeannette H. (Jeannette Howard)
General
Sex variant women in literature : $b A historical and quantitative survey
Foster, Jeannette H. (Jeannette Howard)
Lesbians in literature; Sex in literature; Women in literature
Almost immediately the foundations of the hereditary theory were
threatened. For Freud’s thesis, as no one needs reminding in this
generation, was that the human personality passes through several phases
of sexual development, beginning in earliest infancy, and reaching
maturity only with complete heterosexual experience. All individuals, he
said, are potentially bisexual. In some, the homosexual component
becomes conscious and active, and unless this phase gives way with the
passing of adolescence to the heterosexual, the personality remains
arrested and immature. Such an arrest constitutes neurosis, whether or
not it becomes troublesome enough to demand psychiatric attention.
As is obvious, this view contradicts the hereditary theory at several
important points. It holds that the homosexual is not born, but made by
conditioning factors in his early life, chiefly family relations before
he is five years of age. He can usually overcome his neurosis if he
earnestly wishes, at least with the aid of psychiatry; therefore, he may
be considered more or less responsible for his state if he persists in
it. Furthermore, the bisexual is nearer to maturity than the homosexual.
This conclusion is particularly opposed to the tenets of the
Ellis-Hirschfeld school, which classed frigidity to the opposite sex as
a mark of “true,” that is, innate and blameless, homosexuals. The battle
between the hereditary and the Freudian theories can be detected in a
good deal of twentieth-century variant fiction.
The pendulum swung again toward physical causation with the development
of endocrinology, which at first held the individual’s glandular
endowment responsible for his sexual inclinations. This science began as
a branch of general physiology, and acquired major sexual importance
only with Steinach’s and Voronoff’s famous experiments in rejuvenation
through graft of sex glands or other reinforcement of sex hormones. In
the variant field, endocrinologists were first concerned with glandular
influence on secondary sex characteristics—breast development, hair
distribution, vocal register, et cetera. Thus, during the 1920s and
1930s a number of physicians were attempting to cure homosexuals by
dosing them with hormones which reinforced their biological sex and
tended to decrease variant traits. These experiments enjoyed some
publicity in medical literature but had only limited success. In the
meantime, disciples of Freud were bringing in evidence that
psychological disturbances alter endocrine balance. The final compromise
is the current school of psychosomatic medicine.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account