Sex variant women in literature : $b A historical and quantitative surveyFoster, Jeannette H. (Jeannette Howard)
General
Sex variant women in literature : $b A historical and quantitative survey
Foster, Jeannette H. (Jeannette Howard)
Lesbians in literature; Sex in literature; Women in literature
Rachilde continued for several decades to produce novels, in some of
which lesbian women made brief appearances too slight to consider here.
Her one later sustained treatment of homosexuality, (which ran serially
in the _Mercure de France_ as _Les Factices_ and was published in book
form as _Les Hors Natures_) dealt with men. In the reviews of fiction
which she contributed to her husband’s periodical from 1896 to the
1930s, she maintained the same attitude of superiority to female
variance expressed by her own Raoule de Vénérande, but she regularly
included lesbian novels in her review list and seldom failed to indicate
their theme. Thus she provided an index of sorts to such fiction over a
period of nearly forty years. When, during the 1890s, criticism was
leveled at the _Mercure_ for its consistent noting of fictional
“decadence,” Vallette replied in a sharp editorial that theirs was the
only periodical whose reviews gave anything resembling an honest picture
of contemporary writing.[12]
The Shadow of Feminism
In Rachilde’s two novels just considered, women’s deliberate adoption of
male attire and outlook figures for the first time in half a century;
that is, since the appearance of _Fragoletta_ and _Mademoiselle de
Maupin_. No significant rebellion against the feminine role is evident
in Zola’s or even Maupassant’s references to transvestism among
prostitutes nor in other variant French fiction before 1890. In other
countries, however, what is now termed the masculine protest was
receiving considerable attention. Oliver Wendell Holmes and Henry James
in America, Olive Schreiner in South Africa, and August Strindberg in
Sweden all contributed observations, even though the phenomenon appears
in their work under widely differing guises and sometimes is only
tenuously related to variance.
Dr. Holmes, versatile contributor to both medicine and letters, would
today undoubtedly have been a psychiatrist. Throughout his life he was
preoccupied with intersexual personality in women, and he explored it at
least tentatively in each of his three novels: _Elsie Venner_ (1859),
_The Guardian Angel_ (1867), and _A Mortal Antipathy_ (1885). Of these a
modern psychiatrist, Dr. Clarence Oberndorf, has observed:
The theory of bisexuality and the importance of bisexual components
in influencing the character of individuals is more than implied in
each one of his abnormal personalities. The masculine traits in
childhood of both Elsie Venner and Myrtle Hazard [in _The Guardian
Angel_], something of a tomboy, are unmistakable. The bisexual theme
becomes even clearer in _A Mortal Antipathy_, where Holmes repeatedly
contrasts the femininity of Euthemia Tower with the masculinity of
Lurida Vincent, and it is apparent that he has but little sympathy
with the latter.[13]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account