Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
“Research is largely dependent on individual enthusiasm, but can
certainly be stimulated and maintained by the co-operation of the
senior medical staff. There is reason to fear that such work is
undertaken in some quarters without any guidance or encouragement
from seniors, and laborious original investigations have received
little or no recognition from those in authority.... Although there
is no uniformity of practice, report is made that in many asylums
junior medical officers are placed in charge of chronic cases only,
and have no duties in reference to the treatment of newly-admitted
cases. This appears to be most undesirable. Junior medical officers,
in addition to their statutory routine duties, should be given the
opportunity of co-operation with their senior colleagues in clinical
work. Consultation between the various members of the medical staff in
doubtful and interesting cases is very desirable....” (p. 30.)
If the reader will pause for a moment, and in imagination put himself
in the position of a junior medical officer, “_placed in charge of
chronic cases only_,” he will not only come to understand the “stunting
of ambition and the gradual loss of interest in scientific medicine” of
which he has read, but may admire the self-restraint of a report which
can speak in temperate language of such a state of affairs.
Another difficulty that stands in the way of this urgently needed
reform in medical education is the inadequacy of the text-books
available for the student. In many of these text-books the introductory
chapters contain some, often irrelevant,[86] morbid anatomy, and the
remainder deals with “psychology.” The latter frequently consists
largely of anecdotes, often “funny” and sometimes more appropriate
to the “after-dinner” hour than the text-book, and enumerations of
the mental _symptoms_ of the cases. In practically every available
English text-book the latter are depicted only as they appear after
they have become fixed, habitual, hardened and rationalised. Such
“units” of terminology as “delusions,” or “delusions of persecution,”
“hallucinations,” etc., are freely used. In other departments of
clinical medicine the text-book writer does not describe a patient as
suffering from a cough, and leave it at that; yet the phrase “suffering
from delusions” is the veriest commonplace in the text-books. Yet
just as a cough may be due to tuberculosis of the lung, pharyngeal
irritation, hysteria, or a variety of utterly different causes, each
class of case requiring a different treatment, so the causes of
delusions are even more infinitely varied.
But the gravest defects of these text-books is that few of them make
any attempt whatever, except in the case of such forms of disease as
have an organic cause, to explain the _development_ of the trouble, the
precise nature of the primary cause or causes and the way in which the
disturbance of the patient’s personality has been gradually effected.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account