Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
We submit, then, that the clinic system is a decided advance in the
treatment of mental disorder which other countries have adopted while
for years we have stood by with folded hands.[89] From the humanitarian
and the scientific point of view there is everything to be said in
favour of the clinic. The practical Englishman will, however, ask “What
about the financial aspect? Are not these institutions, with their
heavy proportion of doctors and nurses to patients, prohibitively
expensive?”
The answer to this question is that certainly the clinic is relatively
more expensive than the asylum. But since the function of the clinic
is to save as many patients as possible from entering the asylum, it
is obvious that its expense must be judged from a special standpoint.
The maintenance of a repair shop is always comparatively costly,
whether the material to be mended be human or not. The cost per day
of repairing a motor car is usually distinctly higher than the daily
charge for garaging it in its broken-down state. Yet we gladly pay the
higher charge for the simple reasons that a motor car in its garage is
of no use to us, and that the daily charge for housing the car would
amount to a colossal figure if paid for many years. Cannot we apply the
same reasoning to the case of the mentally disordered human being?
This is to take the very lowest view of the value of the individual to
the community. Yet it would seem that the British public, so far, has
been impervious even to this financial consideration.
But, it may still be asked, cannot the doctors in the asylums carry
out the work suggested? The answer to this is, that apart from the
undesirability of allowing a patient suffering from a mild mental
disorder to be associated with an institution housing the definitely
insane, it is a physical impossibility for the asylum doctors to do
this work so long as the present proportion of doctors to patients
remains unchanged. How many members of the British public realise the
fact that it is quite usual for an asylum doctor to be in charge of
at least 400 patients, and that this number sometimes rises to 600?
When it is remembered that insane patients are even more prone than
the average person to suffer from physical ailments, and that their
mental disorders are infinitely complicated by the delay incurred
before they come under medical care, it becomes clear that the doctor
who would succeed in treating such patients individually would require
titanic energy and the addition of at least twenty-four more hours to
each of his working days. We cannot therefore compare the staff of a
clinic with that of a British asylum, for the staff of the latter is
lamentably and obviously too small.
Regarding the financial aspect of the question we may quote again from
Dr. Rows’ article:—
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account