"Mr. George Rattar was out of the firm, sir, years ago," the Superintendent assured him. "No, it couldna be that." "And Mr. George Rattar certainly died a short time ago, did he?" "I can show you the paper with his death in it. I kept it as a kind of record of the end of him." He fetched the paper and Carrington after looking at it for a few minutes, remarked: "I see here an advertisement stating that Mr. Rattar lost a ring." "Yes," said the Superintendent, "that was a funny thing because it's not often a gentleman loses a ring off his hand. I've half wondered since whether it was connected with a story of Mr. Rattar's maid that his house had been broken into." "When was that?" "Curiously enough it was the very night Sir Reginald was murdered." Carrington's chair squeaked on the floor as he sat up sharply. "The very night of the murder?" he repeated. "Why has this never come out before?" The stolid Superintendent looked at him in surprise. "But what connection could there possibly be, sir? Mr. Rattar thought nothing of it himself and just mentioned it so that I would know it was a mere story, in case his servants started talking about it." "But you yourself seemed just now to think that it might not be a mere story." "Oh, that was just a kind o' idea," said the Superintendent easily. "It only came in my mind when the ring was never recovered." "What were the exact facts?" demanded Carrington. "Oh," said the Superintendent vaguely, "there was something about a window looking as if it had been entered, but really, sir, Mr. Rattar paid so little attention to it himself, and we were that taken up by the Keldale case that I made no special note of it." "Did the servants ever speak of it again?" "Everybody was that taken up about the murder that I doubt if they've minded on it any further." Carrington was silent for a few moments. "Are the servants intelligent girls?" he enquired. "Oh, quite average intelligent. In fact, the housemaid is a particular decent sort of a girl." At this point, Mr. Carrington's interest in the subject seemed to wane, and after a few pleasant generalities, he thanked the Superintendent for his courtesy, and strolled down to the hotel for lunch. This time his air as he walked was noticeably brisker and his eye decidedly brighter. About three o'clock that afternoon came a ring at the front door bell of Mr. Simon Rattar's commodious villa. Mary MacLean declared afterwards that she had a presentiment when she heard it, but then the poor girl had been rather troubled with presentiments lately. When she opened the front door she saw a particularly polite and agreeable looking gentleman adorned with that unmistakeable mark of fashion, a single eyeglass; and the gentleman saw a pleasant looking but evidently high strung and nervous young woman.