[Footnote 101: But see the dictum quoted by Scott in a somewhat over-emphatic way from Ellis's _Specimens of the Early English Poets_, to the effect that Chaucer's "peculiar ornaments of style, consisting in an affectation of splendour, and especially of latinity," were perhaps his special contribution to the improvement of English poetry. (_Edinburgh Review_, April, 1804.) Scott said of Dunbar, "This darling of the Scottish muses has been justly raised to a level with Chaucer by every judge of poetry to whom his obsolete language has not rendered him unintelligible." (_Memoir of Bannatyne_, p. 14.) After naming the various qualities in which Dunbar was Chaucer's rival, he pronounces the Scottish poet inferior in the use of pathos. The relative position here assigned to the two poets seems to be rather an exaltation of Dunbar than a degradation of Chaucer.] [Footnote 102: _Lockhart_, Vol. I, p. 408.] [Footnote 103: _Dryden_, Vol. XI, p. 245.] [Footnote 104: _Dryden_, Vol. XI, p. 396.] [Footnote 105: _Ibid._, Vol. VI, p. 243.] [Footnote 106: _Ibid._, Vol. XI, p. 338.] [Footnote 107: The discussion of popular superstitions given in the introduction to the _Minstrelsy_ and in the Essay on Fairies, which is prefixed to the ballad of _Young Tamlane_, suggests comparison with the _Letters on Demonology and Witchcraft_ which Scott wrote in the year before he died. He collected a remarkable library in regard to superstition, and thought at various times of making a book on the subject, but the project was pushed aside for other matters until 1831. The _Letters_ which he wrote then are full of pleasant anecdote and judicious comment, and though they lack the vigor of his earlier work they have remained fairly popular. An edition of Kirk's _Secret Commonwealth of Elves and Fairies_, published in 1815, has been attributed to Scott. (See below, the Bibliography of books edited by Scott.) Reviews of his which have not been mentioned in this chapter, but which naturally connect themselves with the subjects here discussed, are the following: _The Culloden Papers_--an account of the Highland clans, largely narrative (_Quarterly_, January, 1816); Ritson's _Annals of the Caledonians, Picts and Scots_--an article of more than forty pages, discussing the early history of Scotland and the historians who have written upon it (_Quarterly_, July, 1829); Tytler's _History of Scotland_--an article similar to that on Ritson's book (_Quarterly_, November, 1829); Pitcairn's _Ancient Criminal Trials_--a long article, which begins with an extended digression on booksellers and collectors and on the Roxburghe and Bannatyne clubs (_Quarterly_, February, 1831); Sibbald's _Chronicle of Scottish Poetry_--merely a series of notes on special points (_Edinburgh Review_, October, 1803); Southey's _Chronicle of the Cid_ (_Quarterly_, February, 1809).