Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulityDavenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
History
Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulity
Davenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
Common fallacies; Impostors and imposture
A fraud, which perhaps occasioned the greatest regret that ever was
felt in the literary world, has been attributed to Peter Alcyonius,
one of the learned Italians who cultivated literature in the sixteenth
century. He had considerable knowledge of the Greek and Latin tongues,
and wrote rhetorical treatises. He was a long time corrector of
the press at Venice, in the house of Aldus Manutius, and ought to
participate in the praises given to that eminent printer and classical
scholar. He translated some treatises of Aristotle into Latin; but
the execution of them was so severely criticised by Sepulveda, that
Alcyonius, at a great expense, bought up the criticisms of his Spanish
enemy to burn them. Paul Jovius says of him, in his quaint language,
that he was a man of downright plebeian and sordid manners, and such
a slave to his appetite, that in one and the same day he would dine
three or four times, but always at the expense of another; nor was he
altogether so bad a physician in this beastly practice, since, before
he went to bed, he discharged the intemperate load from his stomach.
Alcyonius published a treatise, “De Exilio,” containing many fine
passages; so elegant in fact was it, that he was accused of having
tacked several parts of Cicero “De Gloria” to his own composition, and
then to prevent being convicted of the theft, thrown the manuscript of
Cicero, which was the only one in the world, into the fire. Cicero, in
his twenty-seventh epistle, fifteenth book, writing to Atticus, says,
“I will speedily send you my book, ‘De Gloria.’” That the manuscript
was extant till nearly the period in question would seem to be
indubitable, as it was enumerated by Bernard Giustiniani, the learned
governor of Padua, among the works which he possessed. Along with the
rest of his library, it is said to have been bequeathed to a convent
of nuns, but from that time it could never be found. It was believed
by many, that Peter Alcyonius, who was physician to the monastery,
and to whom the nuns entrusted the management of the library, having
copied into his own treatise all that suited his purpose, from that
of Cicero, had secretly made away with it. This charge was first
brought against Alcyonius by Paul Manutius, and was repeated by Paul
Jovius, and subsequently by other writers; but Tiraboschi seems to have
demonstrated that it is a calumny. It is probable that it was provoked
by the excessive vanity and propensity to sarcasm and satire which
distinguished Alcyonius.
When the Utopia of Sir Thomas More was first published, it occasioned
a pleasant mistake. This political romance represents a perfect but
visionary republic, in an island supposed to have been recently
discovered in America. “As this was the age of discovery (says
Granger), the learned Budæus, and others, took it for a genuine
history, and consider it highly expedient that missionaries should be
sent thither, in order to convert so wise a nation to Christianity.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account