Sober by Act of ParliamentMcKenzie, Fred A. (Fred Arthur)
History
Sober by Act of Parliament
McKenzie, Fred A. (Fred Arthur)
Drinking of alcoholic beverages; License system -- Great Britain; Prohibition -- United States; Temperance
The temperance party did not take its defeat quietly. It maintained that
the failure was due, not to any mistake in the principle of prohibition,
but to erroneous legislation and weakness of administration; and a fresh
agitation was soon started for a more perfect measure. But for some time
action was delayed. The great stumbling-block in the way of the
authorities doing anything is the doubt whether the right to legislate
lies with the federal or the provincial authorities. The decision of the
Privy Council in 1882, while settling the legality of the Scott Act, by no
means made clear the exact line of demarcation between the powers of the
greater and lesser Legislatures on this matter. In order to settle this,
the Ontario Government has submitted to the Supreme Court a constitutional
case which will clear up the matter. As soon as this is decided there, it
will be taken on to the Privy Council, and it is expected that by early
next year the matter may be finally settled.
This doubt has given Dominion politicians a very good excuse for doing
nothing. "When we get a prohibition law in Ontario," said Sir Oliver
Mowatt, the Ontario Premier, in answer to a deputation (20th April, 1893),
"we will want one that is enforced. There is no use in a nominal
prohibition, no use in putting a prohibition law on the statute book,
unless we can, and do, enforce it. You all know that a prohibition law is
difficult of enforcement, as there are too many people interested in its
not being enforced. If a law is not enforced to any extent, it is a
thousand times worse than if there was no such law on the statute book.
Any prohibition law under the present condition of public sentiment is
difficult of enforcement; and if there were any reasonable doubt as to
whether that law is valid or not, it would be hopeless to attempt to
enforce it. We may be sorry for that, and unwilling to believe it; but if
we endeavour to enforce in this country a prohibition law, when there is
not a reasonable certainty of its being valid, it will be a hopeless
task."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account