Social Environment and Moral ProgressWallace, Alfred Russel
Philosophy
Social Environment and Moral Progress
Wallace, Alfred Russel
Natural selection; Social ethics
"If it be true that reason must direct the course of human
evolution, and if it be also true that selection of the fittest
is the only method available for that purpose; then, if we
are to have any race-improvement at all, the dreadful law of
_destruction of the weak and helpless_ must, with Spartan
firmness, be carried out voluntarily and deliberately. Against
such a course all that is best in us revolts."[139:A]
[139:A] Professor Joseph Le Conte, in _The Monist_, Vol.
I., p. 334.
A more recent writer, Dr. W. M. Flinders Petrie, the well-known
Egyptian explorer, has put forward similar views in a tentative manner,
but clearly showing what he thinks our present state of society
requires. Of the compensation to workmen for accident he says:
"The immediate effect upon character is to save the careless,
thoughtless, and incompetent from the results of their faults;
this at once reduces largely the weeding and educational
effects of the bad qualities."
And of old-age pensions his concluding remark is:
"Nature knows of no right to maintenance, but only the
necessity of getting rid of these who need it by mending or
ending them."
Again, as to the huge waste of infant life now going on, which he
admits is preventable and might be saved, he remarks:
"We must agree that it would be of the lower, or lowest type
of careless, thriftless, dirty, and incapable families that
the increase would be obtained. Is it worth while to dilute
our increase of population by 10 per cent. more of the more
inferior kind?"
And he concludes thus:
"This movement is doing away with one of the few remains of
natural weeding out of the unfit that our civilisation has left
us. And it will certainly cause more misery than happiness in
the course of a century."[140:A]
[140:A] _Janus in Modern Life._ By W. M. Flinders
Petrie, D.C.L., F.R.S.
The whole book is full of such statements as the above, for which
neither facts nor arguments are given. It is assumed throughout
that the failures in our modern society are so through their own
fault—they are "wastrels"—and deserve neither pity nor help. He knows
nothing apparently of Dr. Barnardo's work in rescuing these "wastrel"
children from the gutter and the workhouse, treating them well and
kindly, training them in work, and sending many thousands to Canada. A
record of their subsequent life was kept, and it was found that very
few failed to do well, while a very large majority became valuable
citizens in their new home. On the whole, they were in no way inferior
to the average of emigrants who go at their own expense, and who are
admitted to be among the best of our workers.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account