It seemed to me probable that all these conditions and others also had a
part in the trouble, and I suggested that a fundamental way to study the
question would be to take, say, a hundred typical cases of boys coming
before the courts, and have social workers, by gaining their confidence,
make an intimate study of their life-histories, trying to see just how
the conditions of the city had acted upon their development, and where
and why they had gone wrong. The cases would doubtless differ much from
one another, and all together would be likely to indicate a whole system
of improvements tending to make the community a better place for boys to
grow up in. Nothing adequate would be accomplished by working upon any
one cause.
I hold, then, that in all studies of degeneracy aiming to be thorough
and suggest thorough remedies, _the conception of “the cause” should
give way to that of organic development_. Even accidents, viewed
largely, are not isolated causes but the outcome of events which we can
understand and control.
It is easy for a person with a particular bias regarding causes of
degeneration to present statistics which seem to confirm his view: he
has only to display the facts in such a manner as to reveal the
operation of the cause in which he is interested, unconsciously
concealing the truth that others are equally operative. If he is a
student of heredity he will so present matters—and quite honestly,
too—that you will wonder you ever thought anything else of much
importance; but the next man, armed with facts just as cogent, will give
you the same impression regarding education. I suppose there is nothing
which more confuses and discourages the amateur student of society than
this illusive and contradictory character in what seem to be, and often
are, quite trustworthy facts. Unless he can get a commanding and
reconciling view, his case, as a thinker, is hopeless.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account