Under this creed a formidable organism is built up which may win in war
and peace, and thrive for generations, but is doomed to fail sooner or
later because it is adapted to only a part of life, and not to the whole
process. It neglects the dependence of nations upon one another, and
upon civilization as a whole. Its trend to force and to national egoism
presently alienates other states and prepares a hostile combination. The
outraged principle of moral unity reacts by imposing moral isolation,
with the external antagonism and inward degeneration which that
involves. The community of nations being aroused to assert itself
against the disloyal member, the theory proves misleading and action
upon it disastrous.
And yet we must use special points of view, and that of group conflict
has an advantage in the way it illumines the general situation. War is
not the whole of the drama, but, in the past at least, it has been the
crisis, the test that brought everything into action and showed what the
previous development had been. Growth goes on for generations and
peaceful struggles of many sorts take place—industrial rivalry,
competition of classes and parties, conflict of ideas and sentiments—all
having important results, which, however, remain for the most part
obscure. But let a war break out between rival groups and they summon
every element of power to the test, so that we soon learn where, as
regards the development of total force, we have arrived. It is a partial
view, but revealing, and even the moral elements are more fully
displayed than at other times.
The test of war is one that from the dawn of human life down to the
present hour every kind of society, from time to time, has had to meet.
For untold millenniums of prehistoric development the conflict of tribal
groups was a recurring condition for all types of men and forms of
organization, and those which were unsuited to it tended to be destroyed
or discredited. In every part of the inhabited world archæologists find
evidence that forgotten peoples have fought the ground over, and
succeeded one another in its occupation.
Although we cannot reproduce the process in detail, it is instructive to
ask ourselves what sort of men and of social structures might be
expected to hold their own through these millenniums, and so to emerge
into recorded history. We may perceive a variety of requirements,
according as we regard the conditions with reference to the individuals,
considered severally, the family, or the group as a whole.
Individually man must have developed personal prowess—strength, courage,
enterprise, endurance, cunning, and the like, since a tribe lacking in
any of these traits would be in that degree inferior and liable to be
destroyed or enslaved. And the family group must become such as to
insure the fecundity of the tribe and the early care of its children;
which means good mothers, at least, and perhaps also some measure of
constancy and affection in the fathers.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account