The second sort of values are those which must be ascribed to an
institutional system of some sort. Human nature enters into them but is
so transformed in its operation by the system that we regard the latter
as their source, and are justified in doing so by the fact that social
organisms have a growth and values that cannot, practically, be
explained from the standpoint of general human nature. The distinction
is obvious enough if we take a clear instance of it, like the
distinction between religious and ecclesiastical values. Such general
traits of religious psychology as are treated in William James’s
Varieties of Religious Experience, give rise to values that we may call
values of human nature; the values established in the Roman Catholic
Church are a very different matter, though human nature certainly enters
into them. In the same way there are special values for every sort of
institutional development—legal values, political values, military
values, university values, and so on. All technical values come under
this head. Thus in every art there are not only human-nature values in
the shape of phases of beauty open to men at large, but technical
values, springing from the special history and methods of the art, which
only the expert can appreciate.
This distinction, as I have remarked, rests upon the fact that there are
forms of social life having a distinct organic growth, involving
distinct needs and values, which cannot be understood by direct
reference to universal human nature and the conditions that immediately
influence it. I am aware that it may be difficult to make in particular
cases. It resembles most psychological distinctions in offering no sharp
dividing-line, being simply a question of the amount and definiteness of
social tradition and structure involved. All human values are more or
less mediated by special social conditions: they might, perhaps, be
arranged in a scale as to the degree in which they are so mediated;
some, like the taste for salt, hardly at all; others, like the taste for
poetry, a great deal. In dealing with the latter kind we come to a point
on the scale where the social antecedents take on such definite form and
development as to constitute a distinct organism, which must be studied
as such before we can understand the value situation. In moral values,
for example, there are some, like those of loyalty, kindness, and
courage, which spring quite directly from human-nature; others, like the
obligation to go to church on Sunday, are evidently institutional.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account