Social Work; Essays on the Meeting Ground of Doctor and Social WorkerCabot, Richard C. (Richard Clarke)
Science
Social Work; Essays on the Meeting Ground of Doctor and Social Worker
Cabot, Richard C. (Richard Clarke)
Charities, Medical; Friendly visiting; Medical social work -- United States; Social service
I want to connect this subject of fatigue with one of the policies which
should govern medical-social work, namely, that we should be honest both
in diagnosis and in treatment. That is a policy for which I have
struggled and fought for a long time, but which we are still far from
attaining. We have not yet an honest practice of medicine on any large
scale, a frank declaration to patients of what ails them, how they may
avoid its recurrence and so avoid coming to the doctor again. In the
American Red Cross Dispensaries in France we tried to pursue the policy
of honesty in diagnosis and treatment. We were told by wise people at
the beginning that it would not work there, that with French patients it
would not do to explain carefully and honestly what was the matter or
to refuse to give them drugs when we knew that drugs were no use. But
one of the pleasantest experiences of our war work was to find that this
warning was not true. We used the truth exclusively and successfully.
Our success seemed to me natural because on the whole the French are the
most intelligent race that I have ever come in contact with. Hence they
took to this particular part of our policy even better than people take
to it in America.
That policy links itself up with the management of diseased states due
to fatigue and with the explanation of how to prevent getting into poor
condition again. In newspaper advertisements and advertisements in the
street-cars, it is the fashion to state that a given remedy, a given
panacea, "_will cure you in spite of yourself_." That is exactly what
the patient wants. He wants to be put in perfect condition by the first
of March, we will say. Inquiring into his present distress we almost
always find that he has been violating in some obvious way some hygienic
law. But he _wants to be cured without reform_, in spite of persisting
in his bad habits of eating, drinking, sleeping, working, worrying--to
be cured by means of miraculous interference which he thinks a drug will
produce. He wants a tonic, and he often does not take it well when you
tell him that there is no such thing as a tonic. There never was and
presumably there never will be such a thing. A tonic is a thing which
does nature's work, which gives us in a moment artificially what food
and sleep and air and rest and recreation slowly and naturally give us.
There is no such thing. The nearest thing we have to a tonic--a thing
which we sometimes give when people ask for a tonic--is an appetizer.
There are drugs which will help a little in giving an appetite. But only
to that extent can we give a tonic. But this is not what people want to
be told. They want something to take away "that tired feeling." There is
one thing (as unfortunately people discover only too soon) which _will_
take away the feeling of fatigue--alcohol. That is why people take it,
because alcohol, a narcotic as it always is, dulls the sense of fatigue,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account